If you buy fake goods online, you will buy 100 million more!

This recording evidence became the last straw that broke the camel's back!
So far, the trial situation has been completely clear.

Zhang Wei and the other two lawyers gradually became serious, their brows were furrowed, and they racked their brains to think about how to argue.

Originally, this trial was not particularly difficult.

To put it bluntly, after all, the plaintiff and the defendant are related by blood, and the broken bones are still connected. As long as the plaintiff sincerely admits his guilt and admits his mistakes, and promises to support his mother in the future, commutation of sentence should not be a big problem.

Court decisions also have to consider the facts.

Severe sentences for the three unfilial children, or minor punishments and major punishments, so that they will be filial to their parents in the future.

I believe it will not be difficult for the judge to make a choice.

Therefore, as long as the strategy of the lesser defense is followed, the result will not be any worse.

But the problem lies with the three smart parties.

They made their own claims, refused to plead guilty when they came up, and abruptly turned the defense of innocence into a defense of innocence.

The difficulty factor of this trial defense has also directly changed from the original medium-high difficulty to the hell difficulty!

Moreover, it completely disrupted the lawyer's defense strategy and rhythm.

Coupled with the super strength of the plaintiff's lawyer...

With the blessing of multiple buffs, the situation of the defendant's lawyer in this trial can be imagined.

Facing the various evidences listed by Luo Dazhang at this moment, they are completely muggles.

"Lawyer Zhang! Why are you silent again! Hurry up and refute him!" Liu Zhihua gritted his teeth and urged.

Liu Zhigang and Liu Ailing next to him were also urging their lawyers.

They are not mentally retarded, so they can naturally see that the current situation is very unfavorable to them.

All in a hurry.

At this moment, Chen Zhonghan asked in a deep voice: "Defendant, do you have any objection to the evidence presented by the plaintiff?"

Zhang Wei shook his head slowly and said, "No."

The other two lawyers also shook their heads one after another.

Luo Daxiang's chain of evidence is extremely complete, almost impeccable.

There is absolutely no point of argument.

"No? No, Lawyer Zhang, why did you admit defeat?"

Liu Zhihua looked at Zhang Wei in disbelief.

The latter glanced at him, and said lightly: "Why did I admit defeat? Could it be because you didn't listen to orders and talked nonsense? You are still questioning me now!"

Liu Zhihua gritted his teeth, his face became extremely ugly.

He has regretted it now, but unfortunately, it is useless.

However, Zhang Wei still took a responsible attitude, took a deep breath and said: "Our client confessed to the crime committed and admitted to committing the crime of abandonment."

"But it wasn't his intention."

"Our client is not only a son, but also a husband, a father, and the grandfather of a grandson who is about to be born. The burden on his shoulders is very heavy."

"Of course, I'm not saying this to excuse our party, but I just hope that the collegial panel will consider it as appropriate and give our party a lighter sentence."

The crime of abandonment is basically a certainty and there is no way to argue it. Zhang Wei can only try to find a way to get a reduced sentence for the client.

As soon as the words fell, Luo Dazhuang stood up and said: "There is an old saying that filial piety comes first!"

"The word filial piety has run through the civilization of our nation for thousands of years. It is a traditional virtue that kindergarten children know and abide by!"

"As for the defendants, no matter what the reasons are or what difficulties they have, they abandoned their 70-year-old mother and uttered harsh words to her. This behavior is extremely bad!"

"Their behavior not only violated the law, but also violated morality, and crossed the most basic bottom line of being a human being!"

Luo Dazhang narrowed his eyes, glanced at him and said: "If you treat this kind of person with low character and corrupt character, you should be severely punished!"

"Therefore, I implore the collegial panel to impose heavier sentences on the three defendants!"

Luo Dazhuang's voice was loud and powerful, and his impassioned speech touched the hearts of many people.

Zhang Wei frowned slightly, losing the battle.

At this moment, Liu Zhigang's lawyer got up and said, "I've been thinking about a question all the time, what is the meaning of the existence of the law!"

"Is it purely to punish criminals, or to maintain fairness and justice, and to protect the rights and interests of victims?"

"I admit that our client has indeed committed a despicable crime, and the situation is also very bad, but think about it, is a heavy sentence for our client really the best result for the plaintiff?"

"The plaintiff is 72 years old this year. Some illnesses or accidents will inevitably occur in the future, and he also needs the company of his children emotionally."

"Therefore, I suggest that the collegial panel give our client a lighter sentence and let him support his mother and be filial to his mother. This is not only an opportunity for our client, but also the best result for the plaintiff."

Hearing this, Liu Zhigang instinctively refuted.

But when the words came to his lips, he swallowed them back abruptly.

In any case, commuting the sentence first is the most important thing.

As for taking care of my mother... just do one thing in front of the face and another in the back.

At this time, Luo Dazhang stood up and said lightly: "The law is indeed not punished for the sake of punishment, but if someone breaks the law and can escape the punishment, it will definitely reduce the majesty and deterrence of the law, which is not conducive to social stability and harmony. !"

"As for our client's later life, there is no need for defense lawyers to worry about it."

"I have already contacted the nursing home for the client, and she will spend the rest of her life in the nursing home, but the three defendants will have to bear all the expenses. This has been clearly stated in the complaint."

Liu Zhigang's lawyer hurriedly said: "How can living in a nursing home be compared to having children and grandchildren around your knees and sharing a family relationship?"

Luo Dazhang glanced at Liu Zhigang, a sarcasm smile appeared on the corner of his mouth, and said, "Living in a nursing home is indeed not the best choice, but it's better than staying with three unfilial children and getting angry, right?"

"I believe everyone has seen the bad attitude of the three defendants towards our client, and even insulted them."

"And they went to court without any remorse."

"Their performance really doesn't convince me that they will take good care of my client. That's why my client asked to live in a nursing home instead of living with their children."

The three stubborn and hopeless people accused and even insulted their mother in every possible way before the lawsuit. After this lawsuit, the relationship between the two parties deteriorated further. How to do it?
Zheng Aixia will not get any good looks when she is by their side, and she may even be abused!

Instead, go to a nursing home.

At least the attitude of the nurses in the nursing home is better.

Therefore, it is directly stated in the lawsuit in the complaint that Zheng Aixia will be admitted to a nursing home, and all the expenses will be borne by the three defendants.

After a series of events, Zheng Aixia also completely looked away, and pretended that these three unfilial children had never been born.

Going to live in a nursing home by myself, carefree, maybe I can live for a few more years.

If you come to them, you can only be angry, why bother?
After hearing Luo Dazhuang's words, Liu Zhigang's lawyer was also speechless.

In the auditorium.

Jiang Bai nodded slowly.

As expected of Luo Dazhuang, he has the upper hand with one enemy and four.

Of course, this is also inseparable from the god-level performance of the three smart defendants.

In short, the trial has progressed to this point, and there is no suspense anymore.

The crime of abandonment is definitely gone.

Judging from the "rebellious" performance of the three defendants, commutation of sentences is unlikely.

In this regard, the three defenders naturally knew it well, and their faces became more and more ugly.

It's just that if you are in your position, you have to do enough even if you put on a show.

Still trying to argue.

It's a pity that it is useless after all.

Luo Da's adverbials are fast, his words are clear, and his logic is strong. He has the upper hand in the court debate and completely suppressed the three opponents.

In the end, the three defenders gave up struggling one after another.

This also means that the crime of abandonment is a foregone conclusion!

"Lawyer Zhang, this...what's the situation now? Why do I feel so bad." Liu Zhihua asked Zhang Wei anxiously.

Zhang Wei did not speak.

He is very tired now and doesn't want to communicate with the pig teammates.

The criminal case has been debated, but the division of civil liability has not yet been clarified.

Specifically, the ratio of the three children's respective support responsibilities has not yet been determined.

Responsibility for maintenance must be borne.

The Civil Code stipulates that adult children have the obligation to support, support and protect their parents. Of course, there are exceptions. For example, if an adult child has lost his labor force or cannot live independently, he does not need to perform the obligation—and he has no ability to perform it.

However, if there are multiple children, the issue of division of support responsibilities is involved.

Logically speaking, having more children should be an equal distribution of responsibilities, fair and just, and no one should feel unbalanced.

But the reality is often complicated.

After all, there are differences in the financial situation, physical condition, family structure, and nature of work of the children. Some people have better financial conditions and live affluent lives, some are poor and have no fixed home, and some are healthy and disease-free. There are no disasters, some people are weak and often get sick...

If responsibilities are roughly divided evenly, it will inevitably cause some problems.

Therefore, in this case, in terms of the division of civil liability, it is necessary to comprehensively consider the specific circumstances of the three defendants.

This case is relatively simple, after all, Zheng Aixia's only request is money, and it will not involve such issues as who to live in.

What needs to be clarified now is the proportion of Zheng Aixia's alimony (including nursing home expenses, daily expenses, medical expenses, etc.) should be divided.

To put it simply, how much Liu Zhihua, Liu Ailing and Liu Zhigang paid each.

"Boom-"

Chen Zhonghan rapped the gavel and said, "This concludes the debate on the crime of abandonment of the three defendants. Next, we will discuss the division of support responsibilities."

"What do you mean by this?" Liu Zhihua was a little confused.

Zhang Wei explained in a low voice: "It's about how much you three pay."

"Oh!"

Liu Zhihua's pupils shrank instantly, he got up quickly and said:

"Me, although I am the eldest son, I am not young anymore. In addition, I have been running for a taxi all year round, my work and rest are reversed, and my diet is irregular, which has caused many problems in my body. It is estimated that I will be ready to rest after another year of running at most."

"Besides, my grandson is about to be born, and it will be a huge expense at that time, and the burden on the family will increase."

"My younger sister's daughter is already in college and often receives a scholarship. My younger brother's son is also in college and works as a part-time tutor on weekdays, so he can basically cover his own living expenses."

"In contrast, my financial pressure is the greatest. Even if I want to take on more responsibilities, I have more than enough energy."

Liu Zhihua was very emotional.

After all, matters involving money cannot be ignored.

As soon as he finished speaking, Liu Zhigang couldn't wait to say: "I'm the youngest one in the family, and I shouldn't be asked to bear more because of emotion and reason?"

"Besides, my brother didn't have enough money when he bought the house. It was because my mother added a sum of money to be able to afford the house. Most of the money for the house purchase was paid by my mother."

"My brother should take more responsibility!"

Liu Ailing also said immediately: "I am a daughter and enjoy the least rights at home, so I should also bear the least responsibility..."

"You can't say that. When it comes to paying money, you should do what you can, and it has nothing to do with men and women. Although my sister is divorced, her financial conditions are the best. She should take the lead."

"My mother loves my younger brother's grandson, Liu Bo..."

For a time, the three defendants had a heated argument.

Who doesn't want to pay more.

But in fact, their approach is not wise.

Because doing so will easily make the collegial panel think that they are shirking each other and shirking responsibility, which will definitely be harmful to sentencing.

It's a pity that the three of Liu Zhihua didn't understand this, they just didn't want to take on more responsibilities.

As for the three lawyers, they understand this, but it's a pity that their clients are disobedient.

Plaintiffs.

Zheng Aixia shook her head slowly with a sad and disappointed expression.

It seems to be completely desperate for the three children.

Originally, she still had some fantasies in her heart, thinking that if her children woke up in time, she could consider reaching a criminal mediation with them before sentencing.

After all, I still can't bear it.

But now, the behavior of Liu Zhihua and the others broke her heart.

That's it.

That being the case, let the law judge.

The argument between the three of Liu Zhihua became more and more intense, they refused to budge an inch, and their attitudes became tougher and tougher.

Those who blush and have a thick neck directly make the trial court look like a vegetable market.

Finally, after more than ten minutes of noisy, Chen Zhonghan couldn't stand it anymore.

"Boom-"

Chen Zhonghan thumped the gavel heavily, and said with a dark face: "This court investigation is over. The verdicts of the three defendants have been deliberated by the collegial panel. The court is now adjourned!"

After speaking, he left the courtroom directly.

He didn't want to see the three defendants again!
Plaintiffs.

Luo Dazhang looked at Zheng Aixia beside him and said, "Before the verdict, you still have the opportunity to reach a mediation with the defendant, which can save them from criminal punishment. Once the verdict is handed down, it will be a foregone conclusion."

Hearing this, Zheng Aixia's complexion changed slightly, and she fell into a tangle.

After a while.

She let out a long sigh, as if exhausting all her strength, and said in a hoarse voice:
"No, if there is no mediation, the sentence should be judged!"