The Transformers at Hogwarts

Chapter 77 Analysis
Allen sank himself on the recliner in the Gryffindor common room. The elephant's ears worked at this time. Allen controlled his ears to cover his face, shielding the sound and light from the outside world, allowing him to concentrate to think about.

Just now he wanted to write down the oath he made with Professor Quirrell for analysis, but the act of writing the oath was obviously an act of leaking secrets, and Alan was warned by the chill in his heart again.

Allen could only recall the oath at that time in his mind:

You, Alan Phoenix, will you keep a secret between Quirinus Quirrell and yourself?

Combining the experience of previous attempts, Allen now comes to a conclusion: Any act of directly or indirectly revealing secrets will violate the oath.

Allen also wanted to find a Muggle phonograph, record it in a place where no one was around, and then let others discover the phonograph, but then he thought that this behavior was just a variant of writing secrets.

Still have to analyze the logical loopholes in the oath!Allen thought secretly in his heart.

Allen quickly found an exploitable logical loophole in the oath: "Between Quirinus Quirrell and you."

He feels that this limited scope is likely to be used by him, so how should he use this limited condition?Allen thought quickly.

He quickly came up with an answer: The fact that Professor Quirrell wanted to steal the Philosopher's Stone obviously had nothing to do with him, so it was outside this limited range, so could he pass on this information?

This idea cheered up Allen instantly, as long as this message could be conveyed, Voldemort's plan would go bankrupt.

Allen can't wait to try it out, he's in the bustling common room and he can yell out that message.

But when he wanted to try this way, he was surprised to find that the chill in his heart appeared again.

Allen couldn't figure out why for a while, but after thinking twice, an idea appeared in his mind: Has one of his actions become part of Professor Quirrell's big act of stealing the Philosopher's Stone?

Allen immediately thought of Professor Quirrell asking himself what he had seen and heard in the Forbidden Forest during the work-study program the day before every make-up class. Is this behavior part of Professor Quirrell's big act of stealing the Philosopher's Stone?

Allen thought it was very possible: Professor Quirrell asked himself that what he saw in the Forbidden Forest was a secret between him and himself, protected by the power of the oath, if this behavior was part of his plan to steal the Philosopher's Stone , then logically speaking, Professor Quirrell's behavior of stealing the Philosopher's Stone is related to himself, which also made Allen unable to convey the information that Professor Quirrell wanted to steal the Philosopher's Stone.

So the plan to deliver this message was aborted, but for a while, Allen couldn't think of what message could be sent out by using this limited range.
So he can only give up the idea of ​​using the oath to limit the scope of the message.

Then he set his sights on the word "secret", which seems to be useful!After all, not everything is a secret.

So he was going to test out what the scope of this "secret" was?
He took out his quill and notebook, and prepared to write something down, because writing secrets is an act of leaking secrets, so it can trigger the constraints of the unbreakable oath.

He thought for a while, and successfully wrote the first line: Professor Quirrell knows black magic.

Since most wizards know several Dark Arts spells, this isn't much of a secret.

When Allen was about to write the second line "Professor Quirrell knows a lot of black magic", he immediately triggered the constraints of the unbreakable oath, and the chill in his heart reappeared.

Allen looked at the result thoughtfully.

A bold idea suddenly popped into his head: I can definitely repeat Professor Quirrell's name all the time, the name is not a secret!

He wants to try it, but he needs someone who can understand what he means, otherwise it will be useless to say it.

He thought of Hermione instantly, and with her intelligence, she must be able to understand what he meant.

At this time, Hermione just came in through the fat lady's doorway, and Allen hurriedly called her to stop.

Hermione looked at the excited Allen with a puzzled look on her face: "What's wrong with you?"

"Stop asking, listen to me carefully!" Allen said forcefully.

Then he wanted to implement the plan he had just made, but just as he was about to open his mouth, the familiar chill in his heart appeared again
The excited expression on Allen's face suddenly froze, and then slowly disappeared.
He has been completely confused by the binding mechanism of the unbreakable oath.

He didn't even know how he sent Hermione to the girls' dormitory next, he just remembered that Hermione gave him a worried look at the end.

Allen collapsed on the recliner in the Gryffindor common room again, this time his heart was full of bewilderment.

All that happened today has shaken Allen's conjecture about the magical mechanism of this world.

It is really that the mechanism of this unbreakable oath is too intelligent, not as mechanical and rigid as the mechanism of other spells
Allen clutched his head in pain, he felt that his understanding of the nature of this magical world was about to start to shatter
Suddenly, a flash of inspiration flashed in Allen's mind, and he felt that he had figured it all out.
The most important part of the oath he made was the word "conservative"!

"Conservative" is a verb in the oath, and it also expresses a subjective attitude.

The judging mechanism of the binding force is completely dependent on one's own subjective thoughts and attitudes.

Specifically, the restraint mechanism of this oath made by Allen is completely idealistic, but this "idealism" is only Allen's heart-when the idea of ​​wanting to reveal the secret arises in Allen's subjective consciousness, then this idea corresponds to Behavior is judged to be leaking behavior, and then restrained by the restraining force.

Allen quickly found out his notebook, and wrote on it: "Professor Quirrell knows black magic."

He looked at this sentence. When he wrote this sentence, he didn't have the idea of ​​using this sentence to leak the secret, but now he has the idea of ​​writing Professor Quirrell's name a dozen times and showing it to Hermione.

He picked up the quill and wanted to write the name of Professor Quirrell, but just as he was about to write, he found that the chill in his heart appeared again.

He smiled wryly and covered his face with the notebook, knowing that his guess was right.

The restraining force is still so mechanical and rigid, but the restraining force can monitor the ideas in his mind that can be used to leak secrets in real time, and then directly judge the behavior corresponding to this idea as a leaking behavior, so it appears to be so intelligent.

The unbreakable oath is based on the subjective thoughts of the oath-taker to judge whether the oath is violated.

If the oath-taker believes that he has violated the oath by an action, the power of restraint will be triggered when performing this action.

This is why Allen was able to show the symptoms of shocking the unbreakable oath in front of Harry before, because at that time he had no idea of ​​showing the symptoms to leak the secret in his mind, but when he was in front of Professor McGonagall, he had this in his mind Thoughts, and then the restraining power thinks that showing the symptoms of impacting the unbreakable oath restraint in front of others will cause leakage of secrets, and if the secrets are leaked, he will die directly
Allen couldn't think of a way after thinking about it all.
　After the single chapter was released yesterday, many readers expressed their thoughts in the book review area. Many of the thoughts were very constructive. The next development expanded the direction.

　　If you are wrong, you must admit it, and if you are beaten, you must stand at attention!
　　The author has fully realized his directional mistakes in recent creations, and is now ready to bring the direction of the plot and creation back on track.

　　Today's two chapters are to fill in the pits dug before. In tomorrow's chapter, you can clearly feel the adjustment of my creative direction.

　　Finally, I would like to thank all readers for their enthusiastic comments, and welcome more readers to express their own ideas. I will study every opinion you put forward seriously, and your suggestions will probably be written into the next plot by me. oh
　　
　
(End of this chapter)