Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 231 Arguing
Meng Lang has already fought a lot of criminal cases of the first instance, but there are still relatively few criminal cases of the second instance. Now that Wang's case has been taken over, he must pay full attention to it, hoping that Wang will have a good result.

After the judgment of the first instance, unless the evidence is solid, it is difficult for the court of second instance to overturn the result of the first instance, because the court of second instance must respect the judgment of the first instance and cannot overturn it at will.

This is all from the experience of an old lawyer, and Meng Lang naturally knew it, so he also held an analysis meeting on Wang's case.

This time, Tang Furong also participated in the case analysis meeting.

However, Tang Furong is good at civil and commercial cases, and she is not familiar with criminal cases, but one more person will give more strength, so she is also invited to participate in the case analysis meeting.

As soon as Meng Lang introduced the case, the faces of Tang Furong and Niu Zhao turned a little red. This case made the girl sound so embarrassing. Doing that kind of thing can kill people. It seems that this The thing is too dangerous, if men ask to do this again, they must resolutely refuse.

Of course, this was Tang Furong's idea. Niu Zhao was still very innocent, just feeling shy.

As soon as Meng Lang finished speaking, Qiu Xuanxiang smiled and said, "There are so many strange things in the world, and there are all kinds of things. This is the first time I heard that there are such things. How much does this Wang weigh?"

Meng Lang looked at the verdict and said, "The verdict didn't mention it, why are you asking this? Does your weight have something to do with the case?"

Qiu Xuanxiang smiled and said: "It's too important. If Wang is very light, how could such a thing happen? If it is pressed on top, it will not crush Wu to death, right? And Wu must be thin and small. , I can't hold back."

Qiu Xuan said a few words in succession, but Tang Furong didn't respond, her face was calm, while Niu Zhao's face turned even redder, and he couldn't help but say something to Qiu Xuanxiang: "How do you know that something happened? You're talking nonsense."

Qiu Xuanxiang immediately said: "Miss Niu, you don't understand this, right? Didn't you see in the forensic medical certificate that Wu's abdomen was subjected to blunt external force, which caused a sudden increase in intra-abdominal pressure gradient and caused a weak spot in the left diaphragm? Breaking, this blunt external force must be a kind of pressure. When Wang had a relationship with Wu, he exerted too much force and pressed on Wu, causing Wu to be injured and even died."

When Niu Zhao asked such a question, Qiu Xuanxiang not only did not restrain himself, but made it clearer. Those with experience can make up the situation at that time, and those without experience will turn redder.

Niu Zhao got up to pour some tea, and ignored Qiu Xuanxiang.

Unexpectedly, Liu Hu said from the side: "Old Ball, your analysis may not be correct. Maybe Wang accidentally pressed his hand on Wu's body, causing her to be injured and rupture."

"The possibility of this is very low. How could he put his hands on her abdomen? It's impossible." Qiu Xuan opposed.

"Why is it impossible? If he is pressing her with his body, the pressure is balanced. Under normal circumstances, it is impossible to cause injury. This will only happen if he only presses a certain point on her. Therefore, use his hands or elbows to It is very likely that this situation will occur.”

When Liu Hu said this, others suddenly felt that what he said made sense, and Qiu Xuanxiang's words were too absolute. At this time, Niu Zhao came back after pouring the tea.

Hearing that they were still discussing this issue, he turned his head to look at Meng Lang and said, "Meng Lang, do these things they say have anything to do with the case?"

Meng Lang frowned and said, "If it's related, it must be related. If it's not related, it doesn't matter too much. No matter what method he used to cause Wu's injury, the key is to see whether he did it intentionally or not. , if it was intentional, no matter how much he suppressed it, it was intentional, and if it was unintentional, it was a mistake."

"I think it was a mistake." Qiu Xuanxiang said immediately, "Wang and Wu are dating. He is too big, and his body may be obese, which led to this situation, so he should be regarded as negligent rather than intentional."

After Qiu Xuanxiang finished speaking, he was complacent and felt that what he said was very reasonable. Unexpectedly, Liu Hu retorted: "I don't think so. I don't think such things will happen under normal circumstances. Only Wang's actions are very reasonable. Violent, too crazy will cause this to happen, and if his actions are very violent, he should foresee that his actions may cause Wu to be injured, just like, you push a person vigorously, but you say I was unintentional Pushing you, your fall was caused by me unintentionally. This is sophistry, because you should know what consequences you will cause to others when you push people vigorously. In this case, if Wang’s action is too violent, you should know that he His actions will hurt people, not unintentional without any foresight, and after he discovered something wrong with Wu, he delayed sending her to the hospital for treatment. "

Qiu Xuanxiang heard this, and immediately replied: "Even if he foresaw it, if it can be avoided by credulity, it is still a fault."

Liu Hu said: "He should know that this kind of thing will happen, but still do it. This is not a mistake of overconfidence. This is clearly intentional or indirect intentional!"

"No, he knew that this kind of thing would happen, but credulity can be avoided, it is the fault of overconfidence, he can't have a deliberate mentality!" Qiu Xuanxiang argued with Liu Hu.

Meng Lang glanced at them, knocked on the table and said, "Okay, don't argue anymore, if Wang did it on purpose, then there's nothing wrong with this case, if it's negligence, we can still do it, the others Tell me your opinion."

Qiu Xuanxiang immediately said: "The tiger is holding back, we are defending Wang."

After hearing this, Liu Hu could only stare blankly.

Unexpectedly, Meng Lang said, "To analyze a case is to have objections. If there are no objections, how can the truth become clearer?"

After finishing what Qiu Xuanxiang had said, a smile appeared on Liu Hu's face again.

"Miss Niu, tell me." Meng Lang saw that no one was taking the initiative to speak, so he asked Niu Zhao.

Niu Zhao's face had just recovered at this time. Now when Meng Lang asked her, she didn't know what to say. After a while, she said: "I think it's not a loss to sentence him to three years. The victims are all dead, and he just sentenced In three years, even if we defend him as negligent causing death, it is estimated that the sentence will not be reduced. After a long time, we may have wasted our efforts, and the client may not be satisfied.”

(End of this chapter)