Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 262 Mutual Debate

"Excuse me, plaintiff, why did Zhang Cheng climb out of the window?" Niu Zhao asked again after hearing what the plaintiff's lawyer said.

The plaintiff's lawyer replied: "The reason why Zhang Cheng climbed out of the window was because the defendant and others were violently panting. If the defendant and others did not pant, Zhang Cheng could not have climbed out of the window.

After hearing this, Niu Zhao sneered, "May I ask what is the relationship between Zhang Cheng and Wang Juan?"

When Niu Zhao asked such a question, he stopped the plaintiff's lawyer. After thinking for a while, the plaintiff's lawyer replied shamelessly: "What is the relationship between Zhang Cheng and Wang Juan? The existing evidence cannot prove it. Judging from the existing evidence, they It’s just a relationship of ordinary friends.”

Hearing this, Niu Zhao sneered again: "Really? A man and a woman have a room in a hotel in private, is it an ordinary friendship? If it was an ordinary friendship, why would Zhang Cheng avoid it? If he didn't avoid it, would he fall from the building?"

"Zhang Cheng only escaped because the defendant and others kicked the door unreasonably and violently, which frightened Zhang Cheng and caused him to fall from the building." The plaintiff's lawyer argued again.

"Then I would like to ask the plaintiff again, why did the defendant and others kick the door? Is there any hatred between them and Zhang Cheng?" Niu Zhao asked again.

The plaintiff's lawyer blinked and said, "I don't know if they have hatred, but we know that it is illegal for the defendant and others to kick the door violently. It not only damaged the property of the hotel, but also caused Zhang Cheng to fall from the building unfortunately. They There should be responsibility for that.”

"Excuse me, lawyer Fang, the plaintiff, is beating someone illegal?" Niu Zhao suddenly asked, and Meng Lang immediately glanced at her, wondering what she meant by asking.
After hearing this, the plaintiff laughed and said, "Of course beating someone is against the law."

Niu Zhao said, "What about beating someone in self-defense? Is it still illegal?"

These words stopped the other party at once, and Meng Lang instantly understood her intentions, and secretly gave her a thumbs up, high!

"There is no justifiable defense in this case." The plaintiff's lawyer retorted.

Niu Zhaodao: "I know there is no self-defense in this case, but the plaintiff's lawyer arbitrarily believes that the behavior of the defendant and others is illegal, which is as absurd as assuming that all beatings are illegal. The defendant and others did kick in the door, but they Why did they kick the door? It was because they learned that Wang Juan had a room with other men and came to discuss the matter. Just imagine, which man would deal with the problem peacefully and calmly after encountering this kind of situation? The defendant and others did not do anything in advance. They knew who the man inside was, and they had no previous conflicts or disputes with him. They kicked in the door just to find out the truth, just like the police sometimes break in when arresting criminal suspects. This is a way for them to safeguard their rights. There is nothing wrong with the method, on the contrary, Zhang Cheng opened a room with a married woman in private, which violated the law."

When Niu Zhao said this, the judge nodded repeatedly, but the plaintiff’s lawyer retorted: “The behavior of the defendant and others cannot be compared with the police’s arrest. The police’s arrest is the power conferred by the law, and the defendant and others The so-called catching rape, who gave him the right? It is completely two different things. Moreover, even if Zhang Cheng and Wang Juan have other special relationships, it is still a private matter between them. What right does the defendant Li Hao and others have to catch the rape? Wang Juan It is not his personal belongings, it cannot be said that if you marry him, it belongs to him, and Wang Juan has the right to stop and arrest someone when she associates with others!"

Unexpectedly, the plaintiff's lawyer would argue like this. Niu Zhao took a deep breath and said, "May I ask the plaintiff's lawyer, do husband and wife have an obligation to be loyal to each other? If one party violates it, does the other party have the right to stop it?"

The plaintiff's lawyer said: "There is a duty of loyalty between husband and wife, but what if one of the husband and wife violates it? Does the other party have the right to enforce the law against her? This regulation is only for disputes between husband and wife However, if the regulations are violated, the other party has the right to share more when dividing the property, but it cannot be inferred that one party can enforce the law against the other party, and the behavior of the defendant and others kicking the door is legal. Whatever Juan has done, he has no right to kick the door!"

At this point in the debate between the two parties, Niu Zhao felt that the plaintiff's lawyer was too shameless, actually ignoring the rules of mutual loyalty between husband and wife, and arguing that it was wrong for Li Hao and others to catch the adulterer.

Seeing that the plaintiff's lawyer was a little complacent, Meng Lang had no choice but to go on stage. Although Niu Zhao argued well, the debate between her and the plaintiff's lawyer was a bit off topic. No matter how they argued, the argument went to marriage and family.

He took the microphone from the dock and said: "For this case, the defendant believes that two issues need to be clarified. The first question is whether there is a direct causal relationship between Zhang Cheng's falling from the building and the defendant's behavior? In other words, Zhang Cheng Was it the defendant Li Hao and others who kicked him down?"

Lawyer Fang, the plaintiff, heard this and said, "Although the defendant and others did not kick down the door, their kicking down the door caused Zhang Cheng to fall from the building."

Meng Lang asked again: "Then may I ask, will the defendant and others kick the door and cause him to fall?"

"This..." The plaintiff's lawyer was at a loss for words.

"Although it did not necessarily cause him to fall from the building, their kicking the door must have caused Zhang Cheng to panic and cause him to fall!" lawyer Fang, the plaintiff, argued.

After hearing this, Meng Lang said, "That's right, the behavior of the defendant and others will indeed cause others to panic. Not only does he panic, but Wang Juan also panics. Why didn't Wang Juan fall from the building? This involves what the defendant wants to mention The second question is what kind of risk did Zhang Chengcong and Wang Juan take when they entered the hotel room? Is there any causal relationship between this risk and his fall? We know that Zhang Chengcong and Wang Juan’s Although the behavior is not a major illegal behavior, it is absolutely immoral and improper and should be condemned by the society. Zhang Cheng himself should also know that his behavior is immoral. Nervous, I believe Zhang Cheng is no exception, he knew the existence of this risk from beginning to end, but he still did it, then he would have to bear the consequences for it. When the defendant and others came to catch the adulterer, Zhang The man realized that his behavior with Wang Juan would be exposed. In order to avoid the risk of being known, he chose to hide outside the window. This was his own decision, which caused him to fall from the building. For him It is an accident, but it is even more unexpected for the defendant and others, and there is no causal relationship between the two, so the defendant and others cannot bear the responsibility for this kind of compensation."

(End of this chapter)