Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 275 Xiao Hei's Judgment

The matter was such a situation. After Niu Zhao finished explaining the situation to him, Meng Lang wondered whether he was sure of retrial.

Lin's family members were sentenced to lose in the first and second trials. Under such circumstances, it is indeed difficult to turn the case over in a retrial. The two courts have tried it. Will the Provincial High Court overturn the judgment of the first and second trials?
If there are indeed problems in the case, and the problems are obvious, then the Provincial High Court is likely to correct them. However, this case is indeed very controversial, and it is not the kind of case where problems can be seen at a glance.

Lin accompanied a guest to drink, and ended up drinking to death. You say he is a work-related injury. Some people will say, how can it be considered a work-related injury?Can drinking be a job?Moreover, Lin's death was an accident, not a sudden illness. Only a sudden illness death during work in the workplace can be regarded as a work-related injury.

People who opposed it had many reasons, but those who supported it also had reasons, because everyone felt that Lin’s drinking was a kind of entertainment at work, and he couldn’t do without it. After drinking, unfortunately, the food refluxed and died. From a rational point of view, it should be identified as a work injury.

The endless dispute between the two parties means that the case is controversial, and the court's decision is very important in a controversial case. Both the first and second trials ruled that Lin's family lost the case, which shows that the opponents have the upper hand.

The retrial requires the provincial high court to support the other party, but how difficult is it to get the provincial high court to support the other party?

"Miss Niu, retrial is very difficult and takes a long time, why don't you take this case?" Meng Lang thought for a while and said to Niu Zhao.

After hearing this, Niu Zhao said, "Meng Lang, I think this case can be reversed. Think about it, Lin was drinking for the benefit of his work unit. The court said that his drinking was not a job, but is drinking allowed by his work unit? His work unit allowed him to drink alcohol." Yes, and the result was an accidental death after drinking. Does this belong to the case of onset and death in the workplace and working hours? The court stipulates that if a sudden onset occurs in the workplace and working hours and dies within 48 hours, it can be recognized as a work-related injury. And is his sudden death more closely related to work than his illness? After all, he did drink for work? The court’s reasoning is untenable and should be corrected.”

When Niu Zhao said this, Meng Lang's eyes lit up, and he felt that what she said was quite reasonable. The so-called lifting weights is light, Lin's drinking is required and allowed by his unit, so his drinking is definitely not an illegal thing , and did not violate the regulations of the unit. Therefore, his death after drinking is no different from the sudden onset of the disease during working hours and the workplace and his death within 48 hours. It is recognized as a work-related injury. Besides, Lin’s drinking is indeed related to work. Why can’t he be recognized as a work-related injury? What about work-related injuries?
The logic of the court is that Lin's drinking is not necessary for work, but who has the final say on whether it is necessary for work?Shouldn't the unit have the final say?The unit asked him to drink, can he not drink?Now that the unit does not object to identifying him as a work-related injury, why does the Labor Bureau refuse to identify him as a work-related injury?Could it be that they are really afraid of honoring the benefits of work-related injury insurance? Then this is too wrong, the unit has already paid work-related injury insurance.

After Meng Lang's careful analysis, he felt more and more that there was something wrong with this case. Niu Zhao's analysis was correct, and the retrial may turn it over. It seems that Niu Zhao's level is getting higher and higher.

Thinking of the end, Meng Lang patted the table and said, "Miss Niu, let's leave this case to the next one. We will go to the provincial high court to appeal for Lin's family."

As soon as the case was over, he asked Niu Zhao to write an application for retrial, put forward several reasons, and then submit it to the Provincial High Court.

However, after submitting it to the Provincial High Court, there was no movement. Although he knew that the retrial process was long and difficult, there was no movement and the parties were anxious, so he had to find a way to remind him.

But before going to see the judge of the Provincial High Court, Meng Lang suddenly thought of Xiao Hei's matter. Xiao Hei has grown to 40.00% now, and his sense of justice is getting stronger and stronger. Whether this case can be won or not, should Xiao Hei judge? ?
Thinking of this, he entered the light space, fed food to Xiao Hei, and then said to Xiao Hei: "Xiao Hei, I have a problem now, can you help me judge whether the case should be won or not?"

After eating and drinking, Xiao Hei was very energetic, so he nodded at him. Meng Lang was secretly happy when he saw him. It seemed that Xiao Hei could understand what he said now.

If this is the case, if you encounter any problems in the future, you can talk to Xiao Hei and ask him to check it out first.

Meng Lang told Xiao Hei about the situation of the case. Xiao Hei squatted on the ground with wide eyes and listened to him without moving. It will look so cute.

After he finished speaking, he waited to see how Xiao Hei would react. He saw that Xiao Hei turned around several times on the spot, which made people feel a little restless. .

"Hit the tree again?" Meng Lang's head grew dizzy in an instant. Can he stop hitting the tree? If he hits it again, all the trees in this space will really lose their skin.

Seeing that Xiao Hei kept bumping into trees, Meng Lang wanted to stop him, but suddenly realized that Xiao Hei only bumped into trees because he encountered injustice. If this was the case, it meant that the court's judgment was wrong. There is still plenty of room for review.

After Xiao Hei hit the tree, he turned around, opened his eyes to look at him, and yelled a few times. The look in his eyes made people feel that the matter was innocent, meaning that he wanted him to help turn the case over and achieve fairness and justice.

Meng Lang hurried over, patted its head and said, "Xiao Hei, I understand. The case was wrongly judged. I will try my best to help the client to turn the case over, but you have to help me secretly."

Hearing this, Xiao Hei nodded quickly.

Now that Xiao Hei believed that there was something wrong with the case, Meng Lang had a solid idea in his heart, and Xiao Hei would secretly help him, so the success rate of the retrial of the case would be very high.

At this time, Niu Zhao was also impatient, and wanted to go to the judge of the Provincial High Court with him to discuss whether the case would be feasible, and to give an explanation as soon as possible. If it could not be retried, they could tell the parties in time.

Meng Lang asked her to go to see the judge of the Provincial High Court together. At this time, Niu Zhao's confidence was almost gone. Although she felt that the case was wrongly judged, but there was no movement for such a long time, which showed that the judges of the Provincial High Court were not like this. Look, it may still support the judgment of the first and second instance.

Niu Zhao expressed his worries, and Meng Lang immediately said, "Sister Niu, the case was indeed wrongly judged. We will definitely turn the case over and satisfy the parties concerned."

(End of this chapter)