Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 353 Power of Reason

When the male lawyer in the firm encountered a robbery and rape case, it was like Erha saw dog food. He seemed indifferent on the surface, but his eyes had already betrayed him.

Liu Hu surrendered without betraying his eyes.

After meng lang and liu hu took over the case, they went to the detention center to meet the female client.

The female client's name is Zhang Li, a worker in a garment factory, and she usually lives with her roommate Gillian. Because of conflicts with Gillian in work, she came up with a bad idea to hire someone else to rape her.

Meng Lang and Liu Hu thought about what this woman looked like and whether her face was vicious.

When they arrived at the detention center, their eyes lit up. How could Zhang Li, a very quiet and elegant woman, have such vicious thoughts and become the victim herself? This cycle of reincarnation is too much. I'm in a hurry.

Seeing a lawyer coming to see him, Zhang Li sat in the meeting room and looked up at the two of them with clear eyes, not at all like bad guys who should be locked up.

"Zhang Li, we are lawyers hired by your family. We are here to see you. Are you okay inside?" Meng Lang asked her.

Zhang Li was silent at first, but then nodded.

"Are my parents okay?" Zhang Li said a word.

Meng Lang said: "Your parents are fine, you don't have to worry, things have already happened, as long as you are fine inside, you are really wronged about this matter, you are the victim, but now you have become the defendant, I Attorney He Liu will do his best to help you and let you come out as soon as possible."

"Thank you lawyer." Zhang Li said timidly.

Meng Lang thought for a while and asked, "Do you know Liu, the suspect who robbed and raped you?"

Zhang Li said: "We haven't met in person, we met on the Internet, and we have made videos."

"How did he rape you?" As soon as Meng Lang finished asking, Zhang Li's face turned red, and Liu Hu's heartbeat started to speed up, and he became nervous.

Zhang Li lowered her head and said after a while: "He just broke into our dormitory and raped me. It was dark and I didn't know it was him. After he escaped, I reported him. police."

"How did you know that he raped you later?" Meng Lang asked.

Zhang Lidao: "It was the people from the police station who told me that he and I planned robbery together, so they arrested me too."

"Then did you conspire with him to rob someone else?" Meng Lang asked again.

"I was just angry at the time, and I sent him Gillian's photo, but I didn't give him a reward, and I didn't call me before I came, and he raped me in the end. I don't think I committed a crime. "Zhang Li sounded very wronged and said.

Meng Lang heard this and thought about it, there would be no such stupid person who instigated others to rob and rape others, and ended up being robbed and raped himself. However, he still said to Zhang Li: "Zhang Li, there are several types of crimes. There are completed crimes, attempted crimes, and preparations for committing crimes. If you allow others to rob and rape others, this involves preparations for crimes or attempted crimes. The police station has their reasons for arresting you, but from this aspect, you Well, you also have your reasons, but these reasons need to be explained by our lawyers in order to get a good result for you."

"Lawyer, thank you so much." Zhang Li said hastily.

Meng Lang said, "What kind of conflict do you have with Gillian?"

Zhang Li thought for a while and said, "She just behaves better and likes to speak ill of me in front of the leader."

"In addition to these contradictions, are there other contradictions?"

"No, if there is too much conflict, we won't live in the same room."

Meng Lang nodded.

"How long have you discussed with Liu?"

"Just about a week."

"How did you discuss it?"

"I told him about A-Jiao and was angry with her, so Liu spoke for me. Once I jokingly said to him, you help me rape her so that I can vent my anger. After he listened Just say yes, I can help you with this matter, so don't worry. I thought he was just talking for fun. Later, I told him about Gillian speaking ill of me, and he immediately said, you Tell me where you live now, and I will go and avenge you right away. I told him the address, and then ignored it. As a result, within two days, he came to our place and raped me .”

After hearing these words, meng lang frowned. How should Zhang Li's behavior be judged in this situation?
Although Zhang Li proposed to let Liu Mou rape Gillian, in fact Zhang Li was just a moment of anger and didn't take it too seriously, but Liu Mou took it seriously. Their premeditation was only verbal, and there was no other reason. criminal premeditation, and it was Liu who committed the criminal act. In this situation, can Zhang Li be identified as an accomplice?

For example, if one person says to another person, if you have the ability, go and rob the money, but that person actually robs the money, should that person bear the criminal responsibility for the robbery?

It shouldn't be possible, the man just said something casually, and didn't discuss with him how to rob. To say that he was an accomplice would be a little too much.

Instigating others to commit a crime cannot be so casual, and casual indifference cannot play the role of instigation. The above situation should be that the other person has already had the intention to commit a crime, and the instigation of others does not play a decisive role.

Zhang Li should belong to this kind of situation. Liu may have had the intention of robbing others for a long time, but as soon as Zhang Li brought up the matter, he readily agreed, and after the promise was completed, he went to implement it. In this case, If Zhang Li's criminal responsibility is further pursued, it will be a bit too much to blame Zhang Li.

Zhang Li just wants to take revenge on Gillian. If Zhang Li changes the words, you can help me get revenge on Gillian, and then Liu goes to rape Gillian. In this case, she can be considered an accomplice of the rapist. ?
Zhang Li wanted to take revenge on Gillian, but she had no intention of committing a crime, but just a thought in her heart. If she spent money and hired someone else to revenge Gillian, she would bear criminal responsibility for the consequences. In the case that she did not spend money, others committed crimes more out of their own selfishness. This kind of guilt should not be attributed to Zhang Li, because Zhang Li's abetment behavior is not enough to make Liu commit a crime. , and commit crimes.

Therefore, in order to constitute an abetting crime, a certain causal force must be achieved. If this causal force cannot be achieved, the subjective and objective chains of the crime will be cut off.

Meng Lang thought for a while, and said to Zhang Li, "We will apply for bail for you first, let you out of the detention center, and then defend you to see if we can make you innocent."

(End of this chapter)