Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 486

The defender’s interrogation prescribes the right medicine to let the judge know that the police are inducing Chen Ming to make a transcript. What Chen Ming said in the investigation agency is not true. The source of the recording is unknown, and the public prosecution agency dare not submit it to the court for use as evidence. .

This move hit the weakness of the public prosecution agency, so the defender and Chen Ming spoke with confidence.Chen Ming's explanation was reasonable to a certain extent, so the transcripts made by the investigative agency lost their probative force.

After the defender's questioning, the winning ticket was in hand, Chen Ming had nothing to do with the case, and both the investigative agency and the public prosecution agency got it wrong.

After the defender finished questioning, the judge asked the victim's family what questions did they need to ask?After hearing this, meng lang questioned Chen Ming as the representative of the victim's family.

Facing the victim's family, Chen Ming was in a calm mood. He turned his head and glanced at them. Meng Lang began to ask him, "Did the defendant, Chen Cong, invest in the victim's company through you?"

Chen Ming replied: "Yes."

"Why does he want to invest in the victim's company through you?"

"Because I have business cooperation with Ma Jie and am familiar with him, it happens that my brother has some funds that he wants to invest, so he asked me to help invest in Ma Jie's company."

"Chen Cong invested in Ma Jie's company, why did he invest in your name instead of his own?"

"Isn't it convenient to invest in my name? I have a close relationship with Ma Jie. It's the same whether you use my name or my brother's name, but it's more convenient to use my name."

"Does Ma Jie know that Chen Cong is investing in his company?"

"Yes, I told him."

"Then why did you have a dispute with Ma Jie?"

"Because of the mining cooperation, he wants to run the mine by himself, but I also have shares in the mine, because the relationship has become stalemate."

"What does this have to do with Chen Cong's investment in Ma Jie Company?"

"The relationship between Ma Jie and me has become tense. My brother's investment in his company will definitely not be recovered. My brother was very angry and wanted to ask Ma Jie for it, but he never asked for it back."

"Since it's an investment, not a loan, and investment has to bear risks, why does your brother want to get back the investment?"

"My brother's investment is profitable. If Ma Jie doesn't pay my brother dividends, doesn't my brother just want to get his investment back?"

"Has your brother visited Ma Jie about this matter?"

"I found it."

"Where did you find it?"

"I went to Ma Jie's company to look for him, but Ma Jie ignored him."

"Have you ever called Maj about this?"

"I also looked for it, but Ma Jie ignored it."

"How many times has your brother visited Ma Jie?"

"Many times, my brother ran out of money and wanted to get the money back."

"How many times have you been to Majie?"

"I've also looked for Ma Jie many times."

"Does your brother know that Ma Jie asked you to beat you?"

"I know, but I didn't take it seriously, so just hit it."

"Has your brother ever mentioned to you about taking revenge on Ma Jie?"

"No."

"Have you ever mentioned to him about taking revenge on Ma Jie?"

"No, I didn't think of revenge on him."

"Ma Jie owed your brother money and beat you again. You and your brother never thought of revenge on Ma Jie?"

"No, we are all law-abiding people. If we take revenge on Ma Jie, what's the use of punishing us?"

"You're right, when is the time for retribution, right? But why did your brother take revenge on Ma Jie in the end?"

"I think it has something to do with his taking drugs. He has no money in his hand, and Ma Jie didn't pay him back the money. He did such a stupid thing on the spur of the moment."

"Has your brother ever sued Maj in court for money?"

"No."

"Why not sue? Why not take legal steps to resolve the dispute?"

"My younger brother is an investor. We have consulted a lawyer. It is not easy to sue, so we did not sue."

"If Ma Jie doesn't pay your brother dividends and doesn't return the investment money to your brother, you can sue him according to the investment contract. Why can't you sue him?"

"The lawyer we consulted said that it cannot be sued, and it is useless to sue."

"You and your brother have approached Ma Jie many times, but Ma Jie refused to repay the money. Then on the day of the incident, when your brother asked you where Ma Jie's family lived, what were you thinking? Did you ever think that your brother would take revenge? Marger?"

"I thought he was going to ask Ma Jie for money. He used to ask Ma Jie from his company, but now it is normal to go to his home. As for whether he was going to take revenge on Ma Jie, I didn't know at the time, and I didn’t ask him.”

"Your own brother, I asked you where Ma Jie's family lived. At this time, Ma Jie had just found someone to beat you up. Aren't you afraid that Ma Jie will have a dispute with your brother and you will suffer? You have been beaten. Wouldn't Ma Jie beat your brother? Don't you need to ask what your brother is going to do at this time, and care about your brother?"

"I was in a bad mood at the time, so I didn't think much about it. If he wanted to look for it, he just looked for it. I didn't want to ask more questions."

"You have been dealing with Ma Jie for so many years. You should know who he is, and you also know who your younger brother is. At this critical moment, you acted as a shopkeeper and let your younger brother go find him. Ma Jie, isn't this pushing your brother into the fire pit? Your words are very unreasonable."

"I'm telling the truth. Ma Jie owes my brother money. My brother goes to Ma Jie's house to look for him. It's normal. If I go to the company to look for him and don't pay him, go to his house to look for it. Can I not give it? How could I know?" Thinking that my brother will take revenge on him?"

"Is what is said in the recording true?"

"not real."

"Why not true?"

"I don't know where the recording came from. How could it be true?"

"The source of the recording is indeed unknown, so I asked you if the content in the recording is true? Is the call between you and your brother true?"

"No, I didn't say that."

"What kind of words?"

"It's what my brother told me to take revenge on Ma Jie. I haven't heard it."

"You really haven't heard?"

"I haven't heard it. The recording is fake."

"Which part of the content is forged, can you tell it?"

"It's all forgery. They just want to induce me to testify. I don't know about my brother's revenge on Ma Jie."

"Defendant Chen Ming, I can tell you clearly that what you are saying now is a lie, and what is in the recording is the truth. You also know in your heart whether the recording is true, although it may not be legal evidence. , that is, the source is unknown, but it does not mean that it is not an objective and true evidence, and it can be excluded from the evidence according to the rules of evidence, but whether you have spoken realistically is the key to the question. I hope you will answer after thinking for a few minutes For me, I will give you 1 minute to think now, and then answer me in 1 minute."

(End of this chapter)