Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 7
As soon as Wang Bada's lawyer finished his defense, Zhu Shanyang became anxious and said, "Why did I distort the facts? You must speak according to your conscience!"

"You're blackmailing me!" Wang Ba looked at it, and jumped up and said.

Wang Bada's lawyer smiled and said nothing.

"Silence! What's the matter with you two? Disobey the court discipline, what do you want to do? I warn you again, if you ignore the court discipline again and make a scene, you don't have to participate in the court trial, go out immediately."

The judge warned them both again.

The trial continues.

"Please provide evidence."

Meng lang handed in the IOU.

"The defendant is now invited to cross-examine."

Wang Bada's lawyer began to say: "We do not deny the authenticity of the IOU, nor do we deny that the defendant has borrowed money from the plaintiff, but this IOU clearly says 'we still owe 8000 yuan today', The plaintiff borrowed a total of 3 yuan from the defendant, and now repays 8000 yuan, leaving 2000 yuan unpaid, and now the defendant is willing to return the 2000 yuan to the plaintiff in court, with interest in the lawsuit."

After hearing this, Zhu Shanyang was so angry that he wanted to stand up and curse again, but Meng Lang quickly suppressed him.

After the judge gave permission, Meng Lang said: "The plaintiff does not agree with the defendant's statement. The word 'return' should be read as 'hai' instead of 'huan'. Under normal circumstances, if the defendant returned the plaintiff's 8000 yuan, it should be It's up to the plaintiff to issue him a receipt instead of the defendant writing such an IOU, right?The IOU has always been in the hands of the plaintiff. If the plaintiff wants to wrong the defendant, he can completely erase the words of 8000 yuan on the IOU. In that case, the defendant will have to repay 3 yuan?The defense of the defendant is completely unreasonable! "

As soon as he said this, Zhu Shanyang felt very relieved. What the lawyer said was reasonable, but Wang Bada's face was not good-looking.

However, Wang Bada's lawyer still smiled and said: "You can't say that. The defendant has always trusted the plaintiff very much. He borrowed 2000 yuan and repaid [-] yuan. Because there is still [-] yuan left, he just wrote the IOU. It is also a normal thing to pay [-] yuan on the notice. The defendant does not understand the law and has no precautions. It is not unreasonable for this situation to occur. But the plaintiff is responsible for receiving the receipt. In the body, the plaintiff did not give the defendant a receipt, do you still have to blame the defendant now?"

Wang Bada's lawyer was eloquent, and his words were plausible in an instant, and Zhu Shanyang was very angry immediately, sitting on the plaintiff's seat, trembling all over.

When Wang Bada heard it, he felt happy, and a smile appeared on his face.

After hearing this, the judge asked, "Does the plaintiff have anything to add?"

Meng Lang looked at Wang Bada and his lawyer, and said, "Report to the presiding judge, I have a few questions I want to ask the defendant, and I hope the defendant can answer them himself, and the defendant's lawyer is not allowed to answer."

"can."

"Excuse me, the defendant. You said you paid the plaintiff 8000 yuan. I want to ask you, did you give it in cash or by transfer?"

"Cash, I'm giving you cash."

"Did you get your cash from the bank?"

"If I don't withdraw it from the bank, can it still fall from the sky?"

"Report to the judge, I object to the plaintiff's questioning." As soon as he said this, Wang Bada's lawyer immediately raised his hand to object.

The judge said: "Please explain the reasons for your objection."

"The plaintiff's question is a leading question, which violates the law. The defendant gave the plaintiff cash back, but he didn't withdraw it from the bank. He gave it to the plaintiff because he had cash in advance."

When Meng Lang heard this, he also raised his hand and said, "I object. The defendant's lawyer cannot answer my questions on behalf of the defendant. Now I want to ask the defendant to clarify whether the 8000 yuan was withdrawn from the bank?"

When Wang Bada heard this, he was at a loss for a moment. He didn't know that he had fallen into Meng Lang's trap with his answer just now, so he looked at his lawyer, who secretly signaled him to say no.

"No, I didn't get it from the bank."

"Is that what fell from the sky?"

"I..." Wang Bada slapped himself.

Upon seeing this, the defendant's lawyer ignored the court discipline of raising his hand to apply for a speech, and said directly: "The question asked by the plaintiff's lawyer has nothing to do with this case. Of course, the defendant's money was taken from the bank, but this time the repayment was not directly taken from the bank. , but the cash he previously kept at home, no matter where his money came from, the defendant has returned the plaintiff’s debt.”

The defendant's lawyer is also a master!
I know his purpose of asking Wang Bada like this, but he is a lawyer and cannot answer factual questions on behalf of the client!

"Report to the presiding judge, the defendant's lawyer spoke without permission and violated court discipline, please punish the court!"

Meng Lang immediately pointed out to the court that the plaintiff's lawyer rolled his eyes wildly and no longer smiled.

The judge looked at the defendant's lawyer: "Remind the defendant's lawyer that he is not allowed to speak freely without the court's permission. Questions of fact should be answered by the defendant himself."

"What I said was the same as what my lawyer said, and I have nothing to answer." Seeing this, Wang Bada said immediately.

Meng Lang sneered and asked, "You and your lawyer disagree, whoever said it shall prevail."

"According to what my lawyer said."

As soon as Wang Bada said this, the three judges sitting in the court couldn't help laughing. This Wang Bada was completely fooled by Meng Lang.

Meng Lang couldn't help smiling and said, "How could your lawyer know about this?"

"I told him, what happened!"

"Since you told him about this, why do you still take what he said as standard?"

"I..., I won't answer your question!"

Wang Ba was very annoyed, and the face of the lawyer sitting next to him was as dark as a dark cloud. He didn't expect Meng Lang to ask such tricky questions at a young age.

"Report to the presiding judge, the defendant is lying! It is very clear to him whether the plaintiff's money was withdrawn from the bank, but he answered inconsequentially and inconsistently, which proves his words It’s fake! He only paid back 2000 yuan, and what the plaintiff said is true!”

As soon as Meng Lang said this, the defendant's lawyer immediately retorted: "It doesn't matter whether the defendant got the plaintiff's money from the bank or not! The 8000 yuan was not withdrawn directly from the bank, but in cash from home. The defendant did not lie, it was just that he was nervous and couldn't explain clearly! The plaintiff's lawyer should not arbitrarily say that the defendant's words are false!"

The defendant's lawyer also looks very strong.

"Report to the presiding judge, the plaintiff is now submitting a second set of evidence."

Meng Lang submitted the second set of evidence, the bank statement.

"Presiding judge, the second set of evidence is the bank statement. What I want to prove is that the defendant did not withdraw 8000 yuan in cash within one month before the date of repayment. The words said match, proving that the defendant actually repaid 2000 yuan, not 2000 yuan."

After meng lang finished speaking, the judge handed over the evidence to the defendant for cross-examination.

After the defendant's lawyer read it, he threw the evidence on the table and said, "Report to the presiding judge, the plaintiff did not submit evidence within the time limit for producing evidence, which violated the provisions of the Civil Procedure Law, and the defendant will not cross-examine it."

(End of this chapter)