Gamers Are Fierce

That's it?

Mule Zi felt relieved. He originally thought that the other party would come up with a complicated and complicated case, but he didn't expect it to be much simpler than he imagined.

Of course guilty——

As soon as the mule opened his mouth, the witch floating behind him shouted sharply: Wait!

The mule's movement to open his mouth froze instantly, and his relaxed mind became tense.

Only then did the intelligence broker notice,

The bee man sitting in front of him adjusted his sitting posture subtly.

The angles of its furry orange-yellow bee head and its facial features seem to have changed.

It seemed like he was putting on a...serious expression?

Although, seeing the word serious from the face of a bee sounds a bit unrealistic....

In this script mission, you play the role of a professional lawyer.

The witch said solemnly: If the arguments, arguments, and arguments given are too superficial and crude,

Probably will not pass Bonaparte's test,

The authenticity of the identity was even questioned.

That's right.

The black wooden horse nodded and said: Bonaparte has read all kinds of books including mathematics, philosophy, geography, and history.

The promulgation of the Napoleonic Code established the social order of Western capital countries.

The critical thinking ability is absolutely not bad,

Answering questions hastily will only make you look full of loopholes.

...

Mule's mind was spinning. He understood that the strategy team was right, but how should he speak to pass the opponent's test?

Seemingly mistaking Mule's hesitation as careful consideration, Bee Man nodded in approval and continued to add details to the case.

For example, during the search and rescue process, the mountain collapsed several times, one of which claimed the lives of ten rescuers.

During the rescue process, the Cave Exploration Association's funds were quickly exhausted, and subsequent public donations and statutory appropriations were used to support the rescue work.

Wetmore, the spelunker, first suggested that it might be possible to eat one member of the group, otherwise it would be impossible for the others to survive,

It was also he who proposed drawing lots and claimed that he had brought a pair of dice.

The other four were initially reluctant to respond to the offer, but after Wittmore used a wireless device to talk to the outside world,

They agreed to the proposal and went back and forth on the mathematics of ensuring a fair draw, eventually agreeing to use dice to decide life and death.

However, before the dice were cast, Whetmore, the proposer of the draw, announced his withdrawal from the agreement,

He believed that he should have waited a week before committing this horrific act. Others accused him of going back on his word and insisting on rolling the dice. When it was his turn, a member of the group rolled the dice for him and asked Wetmore to comment on whether he agreed with the dice. impartiality, making a statement,

The latter had no objections, but was eventually murdered and eaten by the other members because the dice turned against him.

call...

Mule let out a long sigh of relief. When he reviewed the entire case again and thought deeply, he realized how incredibly complex this case was.

Absolutely no simple judgment can be given from a single perspective (such as personal moral aesthetics).

I...

Just as the mule was about to speak, he was interrupted by the bee man, Mr. Kevin, you once served as a district attorney, and then changed your career to a lawyer. You have rich professional experience.

But in this case, I wasn't just asking for the advice of a prosecutor or a lawyer;

I need you to give judgment as the authority agent.

Agent of power?

Yes.

The bee man clasped his fingers together and put his hands casually on his raised left thigh, Hades is an important cornerstone for the normal operation of this world.

A thirteen-person council controlled by five dinosaur kings,

Responsible for guiding the souls in the world, washing their memories, judging their crimes, and then reclassifying the souls and putting them into the world.

If Hades ceased to exist, then the world would be desolate and dead due to the lack of biological souls.

At the same time, the negative emotions accumulated in this world will also be projected into the underworld.

If the living beings in this world are despairing, passive, degenerate and numb,

Hades will also become desolate and desolate.

The two worlds interfere with each other and influence each other,

The Council of Thirteen takes on the important task of maintaining the healthy operation of this important machine of Hades.

We need to judge the souls in this world, wash away their sins, and make the dirty souls healthy again.

Thereby promoting the present world to become positive and maintain the balance between the two worlds.

Note that the judgment mentioned here is not just for a certain person or species.

Rather, it is from a very high perspective of the two worlds and carries out macro-control of hundreds of millions of creatures.

The bee man waved his hand and said slowly in a solemn tone: We are judges, but also the makers, executors, implementers of the law, and even the agents of the supreme authority of the two worlds.

We are responsible for the five dinosaur kings and billions of living beings.

I hope you can stand in our shoes, think about morality, law, fairness and justice at the same time, and look at this case from a micro perspective.

...

Mule pursed his lips tightly. He finally realized the difficulty of this mission.

If you observe things from different angles and heights, you will draw different conclusions.

With the mind, will, perseverance, and ability of an ordinary person, it is difficult to transcend one's own limitations and evaluate and judge things both macroscopically and microscopically.

What's more, he is not a lawyer, and he is not even a legal practitioner...

It's so complicated...

The black wooden horse licked his lips, and the tips of his fingers were slightly numb.

In the sight of this coder, all the legal provisions that he found floated.

But these provisions don't seem to be of much help.

The forest cat frowned and said distressedly: Macroscopically and microscopically... No wonder Napoleon turned into a bee. Thinking about this problem all day long, he will go crazy sooner or later.

Stop saying useless things,

The witch, who appeared to be the youngest junior high school student, shook her head and thought: Since we have to stand at a higher angle,

Naturally, we have to abandon the perspective of the five major legal systems, including the European Continental Law System, the Anglo-American Law System, the Indian Law System, and the Oriental Law System.

There is no need to worry about specific legal provisions anymore.

Tsk, it’s really troublesome...

Seeing the confused expression on the forest cat's face, the witch explained casually: The five major legal systems in the world are the five legal systems defined by jurists based on the basic characteristics of laws in various countries around the world.

The common law system applies to Great Britain and the United States. Its characteristic is that past cases are one of the main basis for judges to make judgments. The jury is responsible for determining factual issues based on the evidence, and the judge is responsible for making a judgment.

The European civil law system is applicable to France and Germany. Legal provisions are the main basis for judgment. There is no jury system. The judge determines whether the person is guilty and the degree of punishment.

If this case adopts the European legal system, we can easily make a judgment based on a specific legal provision.

Naturally, there is no need to be so troublesome.

Not as good as,

Li Ang stopped fighting against the bookshelf, turned around, and said calmly to his companion: First ask Bee, is there a universal code of law in Hades?

Can,

The witch nodded and agreed: In front of a mythical species that can destroy you with just one look, it's best to test his original attitude first.

It doesn’t hurt to ask.

After getting the opinions of the strategy team, Mule pretended to have finished thinking and asked Li Ang's question seriously.

Are you talking about the code of law?

Bee nodded, There is a code in Hades.

Hosted the compilation of five dinosaur armies from two thousand years ago.

But that code is for all living things, and the content in it is very vague.

Basically, 'Those who maliciously harm other living beings and produce negative emotions for the purpose of enjoyment without satisfying the needs of survival need to be judged. ’

As the human race expands and society changes with each passing day, humans themselves have an increasing impact on the natural world, and the negative emotions generated by the seven billion humans are becoming more and more serious.

Some of the codes no longer apply.

Bee picked up the wine glass, took a sip of the liquid in the glass with his chewing and sucking mouthparts, and said calmly: We will discuss the question of the code later. Now, I want to hear your answer.

...

The mule was silent for a while, then tapped his fingertips on the table to clearly convey the message 'Help me quickly' to his companions.

Li Ang stared at his companions for a while and found that they were still thinking, so he said: Why don't you say so...

He stated calmly,

After a brief silence, the mule took a deep breath and repeated Li Ang's words word for word.

Sorry, Mr. Bee, as an ordinary person, I am still limited by my own knowledge structure, intelligence level and past experience, so I cannot give an accurate and objective conclusion.

You can only give answers within the scope of your own abilities.

Mule paused, imitated Li Ang, and said slowly in a calm tone: This incident itself has countless angles to analyze.

From the simplest moral and legal principle of murder for life, the four expedition members who murdered and ate their companions should be sentenced to death.

For Hades, it is also crucial to respect the letter of the law, enforce the law according to strict standards, and reduce the human factor,

It can greatly improve the efficiency of legal enforcement and reduce time and labor costs.

The bee man didn't express his position, but just slightly adjusted his sitting posture.

Mule glanced at him and continued, Of course, this judgment process is too simple and crude.

What is the cornerstone of law?

Laws made by civilized humans are based on the possibility of human coexistence.

The fundamental goal of all laws in the world is to promote and improve the coexistence of human beings and regulate the fairness and equality of relationships in the coexistence.

If the basis for people to coexist does not exist - for example, as in the case, only by killing each other can you survive, then the cornerstone supporting the existence of the law will disappear, and the law itself will lose its meaning.

In this case, five trapped people were isolated from the outside world and could not wait for the rescue team.

In this scenario, they are actually in a primitive environment without law. They are not subject to supervision and cannot enjoy the benefits brought by the social contract of law. All their actions are based on the human instinct of survival.

By the same token, they should not be judged ex post facto by a civilized society.

Bee shook his head, Lawyer Kevin, your two views seem to contradict each other.

That's right.

Mule followed Li Ang's example and nodded, The same incident can lead to two completely different views from different angles.

Is it wrong to respect the letter of the law? No.

Is it wrong to respect the spirit of legislation based on human coexistence? nor.

But in the complex real world, there is no simple right or wrong. In other words, the act of simply and crudely evaluating right and wrong is a manifestation of irresponsibility and actively abandons rational thinking, the most important tool for mankind.

Mule pretended to sigh deeply, The basis of law is public recognition.

In the real world without extraordinary abilities, the force that maintains human social relations and order is not guns and weapons, bank deposits, access to information, knowledge level, and social status.

But the recognition between people.

This is an extremely abstract concept. Only with public recognition can there be money, country, and civilization. Even the identity of being re-elected comes from public recognition——

If everyone agrees, the beggar becomes the king. If everyone rejects it, the king can instantly become a beggar.

In this case, most people understand and sympathize with the plight of the four expedition members. Public opinion shows that more than 90% of the people support the expedition members being acquitted or being sentenced to symbolic punishment.

From the perspective that the law must demonstrate public morality and guide morality, these four people should be acquitted.

Bee couldn't help but shook his head when he heard this, Laws enacted by civilization should indeed serve the vast majority of the people.

But the expression of the people's will, that is, public opinion, is of little benefit in enforcing the law.

Public opinion is based on existing evidence, is emotional, can be artificially guided, and may change at any time.

The day before, there was a tsunami of public opinion demanding the release of the suspects.

The next day, as new evidence emerged, public opinion began to clamor for the immediate execution of the suspect.

Assuming that during the investigation, all the evidence can be clearly found and the original facts of the case can be restored, and that the public can think rationally and thoughtfully,

So there is no problem in judging according to the will of the people.

However, in the actual investigation process, there are too many factors interfering, and it is impossible to perfectly restore the original appearance of the case.

Therefore, it is not advisable for public opinion to directly interfere with the ruling. The correct approach is to let public opinion promote the improvement of the law.

oh?

Li Ang's heart moved and he instantly discovered the problem in Bee's words.

The guide mule asked: Even Hades can't restore the original appearance of the case? I thought that Hades would have some kind of props that could perfectly reproduce the life of the soul.

You think quickly.

The bee opened its chewing and sucking mouthparts and made a smiling expression, There is such a tool in Hades, yes.

But this involves another issue, that is, whether the scope of public will should be limited to humans.

We will discuss this later,

Just keep talking.

OK.

Mule also smiled and said: From the perspective of utilitarianism, which is despised but actually exists, the law hopes that everyone can survive.

If conditions do not permit it, then the lives of the majority of people should be guaranteed to be protected - the four people were innocent of their actions.

From a pragmatic perspective, the four expedition members in this case could have waited until someone starved to death before eating the corpse, or they could have eaten their own bodies first, such as toes and other unimportant parts.

They still have the strength to kill, which means they are not in a desperate situation of life and death and do not meet the requirements of the emergency evacuation law - the four people's behavior is guilty.

From a moral perspective, law is revealed morality, and morality is hidden law. Law makers and legal agents are also human beings. In this dilemma, they are likely to make the same choice as the expedition members - if they cannot do it themselves. If you do it, you can't ask others to do it, and the four of them are not guilty.

From the perspective of maintaining the dignity of the law, severely punishing criminal acts can deter potential criminals and thereby maintain social order. If someone with sinister intentions deliberately creates a cave-like dilemma, laissez-faire behavior may lead to larger-scale crimes - four people The behavior is sinful...

etc!

Bee interrupted Mule's words. He leaned forward and asked seriously as never before: Mr. Kevin, you can cite countless viewpoints around this case.

But I'd rather hear your own opinion.

I?

Li Ang lowered his head and thought, thinking about how to speak in order to fit the character of lawyer Kevin.

After a long time, he raised his head, considered and said: Human beings are always limited and can never look at problems beyond themselves, their environment, the times and other factors.

Since this limitation exists forever,

An excellent legal worker must not be able to achieve the perfect balance of morality, fairness and justice.

You can only settle for the next best thing and hand over part of the responsibility to others.

Its external performance,

It's just that some legal professionals have become mechanical, insensitive and indifferent - that is to say, as they learn more about law, they will gradually lose their humanity.

Even some unscrupulous and ignorant legal professionals will be arrogant, think they are superior, and are out of touch with the morality of the masses.

And prides itself on being divorced from mass morality.

Personally, I am not capable of giving a perfect verdict.

Is this the answer you gave after in-depth analysis?

Bee nodded noncommittally, Then,

What if we could give you more than human perspectives and capabilities?