The opening account was stolen, and the backhand recharged 100 million

Hearing this operation, Zhou Yi was stunned for a long time, arguing with himself, isn't he afraid of getting schizophrenic?

It can only be said that the love for debate is really engraved in Fang Daxiang's bones.

Three days passed in a flash, and on August [-], it was time for the court session. @重量/书阁·No fault starting~~

Zhou Yi had seen it in advance, and it was a good day for a court session.

The time came to 08:30 in the morning, and in Fang Dazhuang's office, the computer had been debugged.

Fang Dazhuang himself was sitting in front of the computer, with a natural and peaceful expression on his face.

Zhou Yi and Zhou Xinran sat by and watched.

The trial starts at nine o'clock.

Because the influence of public opinion is really great, the Imperial Capital Internet Court chose to hear the case live.

Of course, no one knew that the Imperial Capital Internet Court had held countless meetings on this case.

These two people are facing each other, and they are facing each other in such a case, the judge must have a high level!

Otherwise, with regard to the temper of some people, they might argue directly with the judge, and it would be embarrassing.

The young judge who was originally in charge should step aside. Seeing this kind of thing, I feel a lot of pressure.

In Qingshi, Professor Tong is naturally ready.

At nine o'clock, the presiding judge in charge of the trial announced the opening of the trial.

Needless to say anything else, one can tell from the bald forehead of this presiding judge that this is a strong man.

At the same time, I don't know how many people flooded into the live broadcast room, because today, some law professors use this live broadcast to teach.

According to many people, this case is likely to become a classic case, and even affect the further codification of civil laws.

Because it is really too typical, and it was a blind spot in the past.

What is the nature of TV start-up ads? Is it the same as those start-up ads on mobile apps?

Or is it of the same nature as the advertisement posted in the elevator room? This is the core point of the case.

Not to mention that there are other TV manufacturers, the jurisprudence of this case will basically determine the jurisprudence of future courts for similar cases.

Although this is only the first instance, the first-instance judgment of the Imperial Capital Internet Court itself can explain a certain situation.

The gavel falls, and the trial begins!

Fang Dazhuang began to read the indictment, the procedure was nothing special.

On the contrary, some viewers who watched the live broadcast were a little suspicious, because this Fang Daxiang looked very calm.

Unlike the rumors, there is no humanity in court.

In front of the computer, Professor Tong was wiping cold sweat. Fortunately, this is online.

I haven't seen you in so many years.The opponent seems to be more aggressive.

There is definitely something wrong with this surname Fang, how could a normal person do such a thing.

Fortunately, I came prepared this time!

With these things in mind, the stage of proof and cross-examination has begun.

Fang Dazhuang came prepared, or he already had an understanding of the format of TV commercials.

Moreover, there are corresponding countermeasures for the doubts that Professor Tong may raise.

The first evidence is the proof of the boot advertisement, which proves that there is such a thing, and it cannot be closed with one click.

This has been notarized. Professor Tong has no objection, because it does exist. What he wants to argue is not whether the boot advertisement is illegal, but whether the proceeds of the boot advertisement should be distributed to users!

Then Fang Dazhang continued to produce other evidences. In addition to some procedural evidences, the most important one, and the ones that Professor Tong valued the most, was that the startup advertisements would be played even when they were not connected to the Internet!

This evidence can be said to be the core evidence of Fang Dazhuang.

Of course, generally speaking, boot ads are in the same form of implantation. Every time you connect to the Internet, the content will be downloaded automatically, and then this part of the content will be used as the next boot advertisement.

So Professor Tong said directly: "As for the evidence itself. (This chapter is not finished!)

Chapter 464 Not only did the other party not delete the article, but also wanted to sue me? Two in one

There is no objection, but there are objections to its probative force. "

"Although boot ads can be played even when you are not connected to the Internet, they are not advertisements based on hardware, but advertisements related to software, cloud services and other content, which must be connected to the Internet."

"Therefore, I think..."

Professor Tong didn't notice that when he said these words, the big shape on the screen flashed a contemptuous smile.

After the proof and cross-examination is completed, the court debate begins.

Zhou Yi could clearly see that Fang Dazhuang felt that he had come now, or rather, he seemed to know the thoughts of the other party, Professor Tong.

Fang Dazhuang did know what the other party was thinking, but he just wanted to prove that boot ads also exist based on content services, so this is no different from those TV program ads.

"If it is turned on through the Internet, then the software and audio and video services of the TV are used, and this part of the service does not belong to the TV hardware itself."

"And the plaintiff continues to use the software and audio and video services of the TV, which will continue to incur costs for the TV manufacturer!"

"That part of the cost has nothing to do with the TV hardware itself. Therefore, setting up the start-up advertisement itself is also taken from the audience and used for the audience."

Professor Tong expressed his core point of view. When you buy a TV, you buy that thing, but that thing does not play programs by itself.

The broadcasting of these programs belongs to the category of the Internet, not hardware, and users do not pay for this part of the content.

Therefore, the advertisements downloaded during this process should not be regarded as advertisements for the hardware itself.

What I said made many people on the Internet start to nod, as if it was indeed the case.

Finally, Fang Dazhuang spoke. The first sentence was that there is no necessary connection between the program itself and the advertisement.

He didn't care about the cost or not, that's the TV manufacturer's business. @重量/书阁·No fault starting~~

You think that the high cost of this part can increase the bidding price, but since you have sold the item at this price, it is regarded as accepting this cost.

The core of the problem is that the advertisements that are downloaded for the next startup every time you connect to the Internet can already be regarded as the advertisements that come with the TV!

"We can see from Evidence [-] that as a user, it is impossible to close this advertisement, so we have reason to believe that this advertisement will still exist even if we do not connect to the Internet in the future!"

"Under such circumstances, I think TV boot ads can already be regarded as hardware-based ads!"

See "Starting Account Stolen, Recharge 100 Million Backhand" for the fastest update, please enter -..- in your browser to view it.

Chapter 464 Not only did the other party not delete the article, but also wanted to sue me? Two in one

.

Chapter 465 Crying, Really Crying

Fang Daxiang's words are categorical. When your advertisement appears with the TV turned on, whether you are connected to the Internet or not will not affect its existence.

And when the user cannot turn it off directly, then you are bound to the hardware of the TV.

After all, it is something that belongs to the category of the Internet. Because of the particularity of boot ads, such as the need to download, it is very different from TV program ads and traditional small post ads.

So many people, including some of Zhou Yi's audience, felt that this thing was different from the elevator advertisement in the example before the trial.

But now being analyzed by Fang Dazhuang in such a stripped-down manner, he suddenly had a feeling.

"In addition; the defendant argued that when the Internet is turned on, services such as audio and video on the TV will incur costs..."

As a well-known law professor, I think the defendant's lawyer has already... ahem, not to mention that the paid content itself is provided by a third-party platform, even if there is a cost, shouldn't the price be clearly marked? "

"I feel that there is a cost for me to provide such a service, so I have to charge a fee? Is there such a reason in this world?"

Zhou Yi beside him had already started to hold back his laughter, and it was obvious that Fang Daxiang couldn't help but sneer at him during the debate.

According to his understanding, that sentence should be followed by a mockery like "The opposing lawyer has started talking nonsense".

However, what Fang Dazhuang said made many viewers who were watching the live broadcast feel that it spoke to their hearts.

As a consumer, what you want most is not whether it is free or not. You may have deceived people by saying that it is free.

But now, who doesn't know that free is the most expensive.

As a result, many companies pretend to be free at every turn, and then cry poor and sell miserably. You see, we lose money every day and we can’t live on... Fang Daxiang’s words are categorical, when your advertisement appears with the TV on , Connecting to the Internet or not does not affect its existence.

And when the user cannot turn it off directly, then you are bound to the hardware of the TV.

After all, it is something that belongs to the category of the Internet. Because of the particularity of boot ads, such as the need to download, it is very different from TV program ads and traditional small post ads.

So many people, including some of Zhou Yi's audience, felt that this thing was different from the elevator advertisement in the example before the trial.

But now being analyzed by Fang Dazhuang in such a stripped-down manner, he suddenly had a feeling.

"In addition; the defendant argued that when the Internet is turned on, services such as audio and video on the TV will incur costs..."

As a well-known law professor, I think the defendant's lawyer has already... ahem, not to mention that the paid content itself is provided by a third-party platform, even if there is a cost, shouldn't the price be clearly marked? "

"I feel that there is a cost for me to provide such a service, so I have to charge a fee? Is there such a reason in this world?"

Zhou Yi beside him had already started to hold back his laughter, and it was obvious that Fang Daxiang couldn't help but sneer at him during the debate.

According to his understanding, that sentence should be followed by a mockery like "The opposing lawyer has started talking nonsense".

However, what Fang Dazhuang said made many viewers who were watching the live broadcast feel that it spoke to their hearts.

As a consumer, what you want most is not whether it is free or not. You may have deceived people by saying that it is free.

But now, who doesn't know that free is the most expensive.

As a result, many companies always claim to be free, and then they cry poorly and sell miserably. You see, we lose money every day and cannot survive...

So why are you still talking about forcing some money from you in other places!

Are you saying that they are free because consumers force them?

The same is true for the TV manufacturers here. You see, we provide you with this audio and video service for free. We have costs, so we need to charge for this advertising fee.

So Fang Dazhuang retorted directly, not to mention whether there is any cost for you, even if there is, you should list all the charges and so on, let's clearly mark the price.

All Professor Tong's views were refuted, of course he was not happy, and began to reply again, but what Zhou Yi didn't expect was that this Professor Tong became anxious first!

.

"I don't think the plaintiff's lawsuit has any practical significance. It's just grandstanding, including the opposing lawyer, for the sake of personal reputation..."

A very classic debate, so classic that many netizens even thought that they were fighting with another troll on the Internet.

The classics say that you can't just start the personal attack directly, leaving aside the facts of the case, you are just grandstanding...

Then, Zhou Yi saw a sense of relief appear on Fang's face, and he became even more excited.

Following Professor Tong's words, the scene of the trial completely changed.

Fang Dazhuang is still presenting the facts and reasoning, but this person can mix all kinds of cynicism into it in the process of reasoning.

"I can learn from other people's lawsuits at this level" and "If I were you, I would find a piece of tofu and kill me as soon as possible" are already considered very light.

Fang Dazhuang attacked Professor Tong from three angles.

Your level, your knowledge, your cultivation.

There is a feeling that Zhuge Kongming scolded Wang Lang to death.

"Professor Tong can be regarded as a well-known law professor in China. Is this the only understanding of the basic principles of civil law? I even feel that the person sitting opposite me is a trainee lawyer who just came in from my law firm..."

The situation was completely chaotic, and Professor Tong knew he had said the wrong thing after he said that sentence.

But there is no way, seeing the man on the other side talking eloquently, I just can't suppress the fire in my heart.

As a result, now, it was really being pressed to the ground and rubbed.

If you just say such a sentence, it may be a personal attack.

But before Fang Dazhang said this, he also gave examples, citing various legal provisions to explain that there are many problems in Professor Tong's claims, some of which are extremely naive...

This is the awesomeness of masters like Fang Dazhuang. Their own words are as strict as machines, and they are extremely good at finding loopholes in the other party's words.

Then use points to break the surface, magnify a mistake, and then use various attacks to directly break your defense.

Next to the presiding judge, the people's assessor looked at the leader and opened his mouth. He actually wanted to say, should we stop it.

After all, it was a public trial, and it was broadcast live. It would be too bad if it was seen by netizens.