Subverted This is the Emperor Chat Group

"However, choosing an advanced system may not necessarily allow the people to obtain actual benefits."

"Even if Wang Mang adopted the well field system, but Wang Mang allowed the people to own the land, you should praise Wang Mang for this!"

........................

Chen Tong rolled his eyes, it really refreshed his views.

Chen Tong:

"Sing praises to the fart!

Wang Mang implemented the well field system, so he distributed the fields to the people?

You really think too much!

Whose interests does the well field system safeguard?

From the date of its birth, the well field system has been safeguarding the interests of the big landlords and nobles, and this system has never been able to benefit the people from the very beginning.

How can it be possible to benefit the people by implementing such a system?

Do you really think that with the implementation of the well field system, the common people can get the land?

you are too naive.

The land reform of Wang Mang in your imagination is far from the land reform of Wang Mang in reality.

When did Wang Mang distribute the nobles' land to the peasants?

Absolutely not!

Not only not, Wang Mang is still frantically exploiting the bottom peasants.

As the spokesperson of Confucianism and the great aristocracy, Wang Mang is originally a vested interest class, and Wang Mang's reform is to solidify the class.

How could he benefit the people?

The life of the people is worse than before, okay! "

........................

what! ?

Many emperors are dumbfounded at this moment.

Zhu Di's face was full of disbelief, and he slapped the table hard, smashing the wine glass at that time.

Execute Your Ten Clans (Hero Lord of the Prosperous Age):

"The well field system is the system of the sage, although I am not interested in imitating the sage."

"But how can the saint system exploit the common people?"

"It really confuses me."

…………

Wang Mang even jumped up and cursed at this moment, if Chen Tong was in front of him, he would definitely spit a mouthful of thick phlegm on Chen Tong's face.

First traverser:

"It's just nonsense."

"The sage lives in the world, how can he exploit the people? How can the sage's methods make the people worse and worse?"

"You are slandering the saint!"

………………

The hat button is really big.

Chen Tong:

"I don't know what the saint is for?"

"But I only know one thing. Any kind of system is actually designed to safeguard the interests of a certain class."

"A sage's heart may be good, but if he doesn't know how to govern a country, then he will only do bad things with good intentions."

"If you want to use the well field system, then you must safeguard the interests of the big landlords. This is the purpose of the well field system."

"No matter who uses it, the result is the same, and it is a disaster for the country and the people."

………………

Chongzhen was completely stunned. The sage admired the well field system, but he was doing harm to the country and the people?

It simply turned his worldview upside down.

Self-hanging southeast branch:

"How is this possible?"

"Even if Wang Mang is bad, but this is the system respected by Confucius!"

"Is Confucius also wrong?"

………………

The emperors were all lost in thought at the moment, and Chen Tong's concept was too wonderful.

This fundamentally negates the way Confucius governed the country.

Friends of wives:

"Chen Tong, you have to explain this thoroughly."

"Why did the well field system implemented by Wang Mang and Confucius eventually become a system that harmed the country and the people?"

"If you don't make it clear, you will be sprayed to death."

........................

Chen Tong shook his neck, he also felt that he should speak clearly.

Chen Tong:

"Why do I say that any use of the well field system, no matter whether it was proposed by Wang Mang or Confucius, is actually a disaster for the country and the people?

That's because the well field system is to protect the interests of the great nobles.

When the well field system was designed, he was protecting the noble class, also known as Shiqing.

And these Shiqing, in the Han Dynasty, should be called aristocratic families!

During Wang Mang's land reform, he never moved the family's land, why didn't he?

First, according to the records in the well field system, these great nobles had the right to enjoy a large amount of arable land, which was their privilege as aristocratic families.

Since Wang Mang wants to choose the well field system, he must abide by the basic rules of the well field system.

He couldn't find a theoretical basis for allocating other people's land theoretically.

Second, when Wang Mang came to power, he represented the interests of the aristocratic family. In order to consolidate his throne, he did not dare to touch the land of the nobles.

Not only did Wang Mang not touch the land of the nobles, he even dared not touch the land of the local powerful.

Because the local tyrants are very powerful in the local area, they can completely make Wang Mang's reputation so bad.

Therefore, Wang Mang learned from the painful experience. When he implemented the well field system, he never touched the land of aristocratic families and local tyrants.

Whose land did Wang Mang get?

In fact, it is the land of stratum farmers.

That is to say, Wang Mang's well field system, the first thing he wants to do is to plunder the land of the bottom farmers unconditionally and at no cost.

Then use these bottom lands and distribute them to farmers who have no land at all.

Wang Mang is exploiting the lower class and pleasing those lower class.

In this way, those vested interests will not be moved, and the support of public opinion can be obtained to the greatest extent.

Because farmers without land have accounted for more than 80% of the entire population base.

This is the real land reform implemented by Wang Mang.

As a result, those farmers with land also went bankrupt!

The entire peasant class of society was not spared, and finally went bankrupt collectively. "

………………

In the chat group, the emperors all breathed a sigh of relief.

This is completely different from the Wang Mang reform they imagined. They thought that Wang Mang was attacking the local tyrants and dividing the land, but Wang Mang turned out to be persecuting the peasant class.

Liu Bang was stunned at the time, he did not expect the harm of the well field system to be so great.

In the past, he only thought that adopting the previous well field system was a big pit, but he didn't understand where the pit was.

But after Chen Tong said this, he felt that his whole body was transparent.

If you use the well field system, you have to follow the basic rules of the well field system. You can't touch the land of those aristocratic families at all.

If you touch it, is it still the Ida system?

Not everyone who kills the white snake is Xu Xian (Sage Monarch of Deception):

"This Wang Mang is simply too disgusting."

"You dare not touch the land of aristocratic families, then you should also touch the land of powerful locals."

"As a result, he didn't dare to offend the aristocratic family, and he didn't even dare to offend the local tycoons."

"He actually took the people at the bottom directly."

"This is a typical example of tearing down the east wall to make up the west wall."

"This is to treat the people at the bottom as monkeys."

"No wonder he was directly overthrown by Xiu'er from our old Liu's family. This guy is digging his own grave!"

........................

Cao Cao was also shocked.

Friends of wives: