Hurricane

In fact, He Yang did not appear in the dock. The one representing Young was Chen Yiwen. The lawyer they hired was called Chen Yanting, who was quite famous in this regard.On the plaintiff's side, it was Xie Lintao, and the attorney was no longer Xue Chao, but a lawyer named Li Anran, who looked very calm.

He Yang was sitting in the auditorium below. He turned his head and saw Xue Chao and a man who looked a little like him not far away. He thought it should be Xue Yitao——Zhu Ao did not appear.

The case began as a court investigation, and the plaintiff spoke first.From the perspective of the invention patent holder, Xie Lintao gave a brief statement on when he had this initial idea, what work he did in the middle, how to make the stomach capsule robot shape, and the process of applying for a patent, and then They reiterated their request to determine Young's patent infringement.

Of course, his patent application time was advanced, that is, on June 6 three years ago.

The content of Chen Yiwen's statement is similar, but unfortunately, the application time of the two patents coincides. The application time for the stomach capsule robot that Young purchased was on June 6, three years ago.This makes them fail to find each other when collecting similar patent information.

It’s just because the United States and China have different review periods for patents, about three years in China, and two and a half to three years in the United States, so there is a time difference. Young obtained the invention patent in the United States in advance, and then came to China to prepare for promotion.

Therefore, even if Young took the US patent, it is impossible for Hongyuan to invalidate their patent.They can only appeal from the aspect of infringement.

Immediately afterwards, the lawyers of both sides provided evidence. In fact, if Hongyuan’s application date was still a year ago, the lawsuit would still be a bit suspenseful. The time to apply was early, although young got the patent certificate in advance, but it was in the United States, not to mention that he applied later and did not apply for pct, but anyone who knows a little bit can judge that young's infringement is a certainty.

Because the ending is too obvious, even though young's proof is not over yet, Hongyuan's attorney, Li Anran, has a relaxed expression on his face. He is sitting there, his back is still straight, but his shoulders are already relaxed. When he got down, He Yang understood that he felt confident in the future.

And Xue Yitao below is alright, he just looks confident, but Xue Chao, who is probably still young and has little experience, can't help but show color on his face and look towards He Yang.When He Yang looked away from Li Anran's face, he happened to catch Xue Chao's movement of looking this way, so he turned his head calmly, and looked at Xue Chao in the auditorium.

Xue Chao is actually about the same age as He Yang, both 27 and [-] years old. He studied law, and after graduating and working in a big law firm for two years, he was called by his uncle to practice law in the company.Because he was held up from the beginning to the end, he was naturally arrogant. Now that he looked at He Yang, he couldn't help but raise the corners of his mouth and shrug his shoulders, which means that we are sorry, we will win.

But He Yang looked calm and breezy, watching him finish his performance like a clown, mouthed three words back to him, and turned his head back.On the contrary, Xue Chao was stunned for a moment. Ordinary people don't study lip language, not to mention that He Yang's mouth shape is not particularly obvious. He tried to imitate He Yang's appearance a few times, but he couldn't get the point. He Yang, he has stopped talking.

At this time, I heard Li Anran say to the judge, "Please allow the court to allow the witness Zhu Ao to testify in court."

In fact, because Zhu Ao is the actual owner of Hongyuan and has an inseparable relationship with the plaintiff, he can indeed be a witness, but the testimony is hardly convincing. Yuan told me, but Zhu Ao still didn’t listen. Xue Chao only thought that Zhu Ao valued this matter too much, and didn’t care. ?

Therefore, Li Anran didn't find his last witness very interesting.

He Yang saw Zhu Ao walking in wearing a suit. He glanced towards the auditorium while he was in action. His eyes stopped at Xue Yitao and He Yang respectively, and then he stood on the witness stand.

Li Anran routinely asked him his name, job, and relationship with Xie Lintao.Zhu Ao explained one by one.Then Li Anran began to ask, "When did Xie Lintao first mention the idea of ​​the stomach capsule robot?" "When did you decide to start a business together?" "When did the research and development make progress?" On the right side with Xie Lintao.

Afterwards, Li Anran casually asked Zhu Ao, "Did you apply for the invention patent for the stomach capsule robot on June 6, three years ago?"

He thought Zhu Ao would give him the same "yes".Unexpectedly, at this time Zhu Ao said firmly, "No."

The voice of those two words was not loud, Li Anran didn't even hear clearly at first, and wanted to continue to ask, "You..." He started talking, and then he came back to his senses, suddenly raised his head and talked with Zhu Ao met, but saw Zhu Ao's eyes were calm and deep, like a lake.

At this time, the auditorium below was in chaos, and the twenty or so observers who hadn't chatted much asked in low voices, "What's the matter? How can he say it's not, isn't he the plaintiff? ?”

Especially Xue Yitao, who was sitting deeply in the chair, suddenly sat upright, frowning and looking at Zhu Ao on the witness stand, his face became more and more ugly.

At this time, I heard Zhu Ao go on, "Our application was not three years ago, but on June 6, a year ago. What we applied for was not an invention patent, but a utility model patent—then At that time, we wanted to go to market as soon as possible, but the examination time for invention patents was too long, so we chose utility model patents that can be granted in only one year. It’s just strange that when I went to the Patent Office to obtain a patent in mid-June this year What I got was this maroon certificate. My application time has also been completely revised."

When Zhu Ao uttered this sound, almost the entire courtroom exploded.The people below talked a lot, and the judge above was also a little depressed-this is not an ordinary civil case, how could the patent be amended at will, which obviously involved some officials of the Patent Office.

It’s just that Zhu Ao’s testimony is well-founded. He took out the deposits of their application for utility model patents that day, the printing time of those patent requests, descriptions, claims, abstracts, and deposit receipts for payment of fees, which were issued during the preliminary examination. It is almost indisputable evidence.

After waiting for Zhu Ao to finish speaking, the judge might also find it tricky. After a little thought, he decided to adjourn the court for 15 minutes. With this order, the discussion below couldn't be suppressed at all, and it suddenly became louder.

But Xue Chao suddenly understood the meaning of He Yang's words, he was saying, "Look down."

Young had been prepared for a long time, they already knew about this matter, no wonder Zhu Ao asked Xie Lintao to be the plaintiff, but he insisted on being the so-called witness, they just wanted to take this opportunity to tell the story.Xue Chao couldn't help being anxious, and cautiously asked Xue Yitao, whose face was darkened, "Uncle, what should I do?"

Xue Yitao saw more than Xue Chao, he took his mobile phone and hurried out, "I'll contact you."

Liao Yong was depressed at this moment, Liao Luchuan brought someone to present fifteen bouquets of flowers to his father, and ended up taking 500 million from his father.He didn't like the money, but when he turned around, Liao Luchuan used the money to buy a modified jeep that was comparable to an armored car. The father wanted to pick up his son, so he took Liao Chengyu away in the third class.

Liao Chengyu didn't want to leave. He almost pulled the door frame straight, and the head teacher also stopped him, but Liao Luchuan had his original household registration in his hand. Who knew that after so many years, he would still keep it This thing is hidden, and now it is taken out.It clearly stated that he was Liao Chengyu's biological father.

In desperation, Liao Chengyu was dragged away by Shengla, and the teacher hurriedly called Liao Yong to report.Liao Yong searched all over the street.As a result, when Xue Yitao called him, Liao Chengyu also called him with his mobile phone. The child's voice was trembling, and he said in a stuttering voice that Liao Luchuan brought him to the hills in the suburbs. Ten centimeters was empty, and he was scared to death.

Liao Yong was going to be scared to death, he was an only seedling.

At this time, Xue Yitao called him and said that he had messed up the matter, how could Liao Yong be in a good mood?He directly threw him a sentence, "I've already taken care of the matter, you know how much is involved in it, no one dares to touch me, but if someone dares to touch you, you can handle it yourself."

Xue Yitao knew that he was really in big trouble at this moment.But the trial was already in progress, and the matter had already been revealed. In front of so many people, even if he dared to give his worth to the judge, no one would dare to accept bribes in public.He regrets it very much now. At the beginning, he thought that he had the chance to win, so he followed the simple procedure and solved it as soon as he wanted.I can only keep hoping that the judge will not pronounce the sentence in court, maybe he can still find a way to walk.

What's more, Li Anran was the one who was angry.As soon as Xue Yitao turned the corner, he heard Li Anran yelling at Xue Chao angrily, "What do you mean I didn't do enough? The evidence you provided is false. I'll tell you from the beginning. Tell me in advance if you have anything to do. It’s good to be prepared, but you still conceal the truth from me, you are also a lawyer, blame me? You are ashamed to say it.”

Li Anran acted as if he was justified in losing, if it was the original Xue Yitao, he would definitely go straight up and tell people to leave.But now, he doesn't have this thought anymore, anyway, the result will be the same for anyone he changes, so there's no need to offend anyone else.

Awaiting the reopening of court.Xue Yitao walked into the second hall almost with a gray face.But this time, it was almost the opposite of the atmosphere just now. Xue Chao looked like he was about to die, and Li Anran was not so relaxed. He is a professional lawyer after all, and he didn't want to lose the battle. During the entire process of the defendant submitting witness evidence, Everyone else was tense, but Li Yanting was much more rigorous than him, and he didn't pick out any faults.

Waiting for the process to be completed, because the facts are clear, the court pronounced the judgment in court, and Hongyuan's lawsuit against young for patent infringement was not established.Even though He Yang knew the result a long time ago, he still breathed a sigh of relief.On the other hand, Xue Yitao probably didn't expect to be sentenced in court, he thought there could be other ways, and his whole body shook.Li Anran left almost as soon as it was over, only Xue Chao helped him to walk out slowly.

He Yang waited for Chen Yiwen, thanked Chen Yanting, and then led the people out of the second hall slowly.After walking a few steps, they saw Xue Yitao, his nephew and uncle Xue Chao, Zhu Ao and Xie Lintao who were confronting each other in the parking lot.

He heard Zhu Ao say to Xue Yitao, "You're thinking of threatening me this time. What did I do wrong? I'm just telling the truth. Even if those people who take things and issue patents are hated, it's Liao Yong and you. People, will you come to me first? You put the cart before the horse. Besides, I advise you not to be so arrogant. This lawsuit is over, but nothing else is over. You wait for my indictment. Hongyuan doesn't need you Such investors."