When the starting boss becomes Chen Yuyi

Chen Qi and Chen He, who was sitting on the dock, looked at each other, they were shocked, they didn't expect such a result, they both stood up from their seats together: "Impossible!"

The lawyer hired by the Chen family bowed his head and sighed with embarrassment: "If you had told me that you planned to use this recording as evidence, I would suggest that you also hire private investigators to investigate the plaintiff's witnesses. More favorable..."

It was originally a trump card, but when it was played, it turned out to be like this. He was really helpless.At first he thought it was just a simple theft lawsuit, but because the amount of money involved in the case was relatively large, all he had to do was to find a way to persuade the judge to give the defendant a lighter sentence, but he didn't expect it to end up like this.

The judge explained to Chen Qi: "If there is evidence, we have the right to rule it invalid without notifying the court in advance. Also, the recording is indeed evidence, but the recording cannot be used alone as evidence for concluding the case. Other evidence is required. Only one tape is required. , we can't convict -- let the prosecution witnesses speak."

Li Chen stood up from the witness stand: "Your Honor, this recording has been cropped, not a complete recording. Under such circumstances, can it not be used as supporting evidence?"

"You say this recording is not complete?" the judge asked.

The phone was in Chen Zhuan's hands at the time. Chen listened to it after transcribing it, and felt that the second half was useless, so he cut out the part where the three of his brothers spoke harshly at Li Chen.

Li Chen nodded: "This recording was made by the relatives of the accused under coercive conditions to induce me to speak out. It's a pity that they cut some parts and couldn't restore the truth."

Chen He was looking forward to the big reversal, but he didn't expect to be beaten up. When he thought that he might be sentenced to prison, he was already flustered to the extreme. Come on, jumped up and shouted: "Chen Yuyi, what did you say, do you have the guts to say it again?!"

Li Chen spread his hands and shrugged his shoulders innocently: "You saw that he dared to do this in front of you, so you can see how he should treat me in private."

"The defendant, please control his emotions." The judge was a little angry. He had never seen such an arrogant person before, and he dared to act aggressively in court.

Li Xi also said: "Your Honor, I can also testify on this point. Yesterday morning at around 07:30, I was going to the office with Yu Yi, when I was stopped by three people, Chen Qi, Chen Cheng and Chen Zhuan. , the attitude is very bad, and there is a posture of hitting people, Yu Yi is afraid of accidents, and he was forced to admit it under their aggressiveness."

The presiding judge had read the testimonies of the parties before the trial. At that time, except for Chen's family, everyone else insisted that Chen He was the only person who had physical contact with Li Xi, and the wallet was found on Chen He's body. , plus a lot of witnesses, it can basically be said that the evidence is solid, and the case has been settled.

He himself did not believe that it was Li Chen who deliberately framed him. He was still thinking about it when he heard Li Chen say: "On the day of the incident, I was standing side by side with Shi Lang, because the defendant rushed over and wanted to hit me. , Shi Lang walked between us to block it, and it was at this time that he had brief physical contact with the defendant, and it was at that time that the wallet was stolen. He said that I stole someone's wallet and stuffed it on Chen He , It’s really nonsense, I also stood half a meter away from them recently.”

The place where the crime happened was close to a traffic intersection, and the camera recorded part of the image. Although it was not clear, the positions of several people could still be clearly distinguished.

The judge flipped through the video report sent by the police station and knew that what Li Chen said was true, so he looked at Chen He: "Does the defendant agree with what the witness said?"

Chen He shook his head in disbelief: "I didn't do it, he was lying, he was lying!"

It can be said that it is impossible to reverse the case now, and the only thing that can be won is a light sentence.Lawyer Chen's family stood up and said, "Your Honor, my client was emotional before the case, and it was also caused by a misunderstanding that a relative almost got into a car accident. Please forgive me, Your Honor."

"Which one was involved in the car accident?" Strictly speaking, this was a combined traffic accident case and theft case. The judge looked at the witness stand.

Chen Taohua stood up with tears in her eyes: "I was the one who saw Yu Yi across the road and was so excited that I rushed across the road to find him..."

The lawyer of the Chen family heard this well, and asked deliberately: "Are you so excited that you don't even care about the road? Ms. Chen, why do you have such a big reaction?"

Chen Taohua looked timidly at Li Chen, then at Li Xi specifically, and whispered, "Because I haven't seen Yu Yi for five years, and I haven't even called him, I don't know He has already returned from the United States, so I am very happy to see him..."

"You mean that the plaintiff's witness hasn't contacted his family for five years, and he didn't even notify you of his return?" The defendant's lawyer repeated it deliberately, seeing Chen Taohua nod, and said to the judge, "The relationship between the plaintiff's witness and his family is so bad. , we don't seem to be able to completely rule out the possibility of him perjury..."

"Against the defendant's lawyer maliciously speculating about my friend, we are conducting a guilty plea. Unless you show evidence that my friend committed perjury, you are just wasting everyone's time." Li Xi interrupted loudly.

The judge nodded: "The objection is valid."

Li Chen sneered: "No matter how bad my relationship with my family is, I would never accuse them of stealing. Unfortunately, my respect for others does not mean that others respect me. When Chen Taohua was almost hit by a car, The defendant rushed over regardless of March 21 and [-], and falsely accused me of intentional murder."

This involved another case. At this time, Li Chen's identity had changed, and the judge signaled that he could sit on the plaintiff's seat.

Li Chen pretended and sighed: "Not only did he insist that I conspired with someone to kill someone, he even beat me. Later, he was arrested for stealing someone's wallet, and Chen Qi and the other three stopped me Record me. The behavior of this group of people has seriously threatened my personal safety, and I hope to apply to the court for an injunction to prohibit them from approaching within ten meters of me."

The judge flipped through the video record at the time of the incident: "It was clearly filmed at the crossroads that the plaintiff first waved to stop the taxi, and Chen Taohua rushed over when the taxi was halfway through the U-turn. According to the sequence of events, it is obvious that It was just an accident."

Even if the responsibility for the accident was judged, it was Chen Taohua's reckless behavior that led the accident.The judge felt very delicate that Chen He could make up so much in a flash.

"Actually, it's not the first time they have scolded me for no reason, because there are so many times that I can't remember most of them." Li Chen said while tilting his head slightly as if thinking about memories. Come on, "But I remember an incident eight years ago clearly—I believe you have read the materials I submitted."

"I and the jury have already read and verified it," the judge affirmed the credibility of his words, "We can pass your application for restraining order against Chen Cheng and Chen He."

Chen Cheng mainly scolded him for the snake release incident, but this time it was Chen He who kept slandering him for killing people. Chen Qi and Chen Zhuan barely stayed out of the incident, so they would not pass all four applications.

Li Xi immediately objected: "But yesterday Chen Qi and Chen Zhuan also took part in persecuting my friend and endangering his personal safety. I hope the judge and the jury can reconsider."

"We will also consider the situation you said. If the suspect shows any intention to harm, we will issue a re-injunction order." After all, the court is about evidence, although Li Chen and Li Xi kept saying that the four brothers of the Chen family wished they could do it. Killing them, to be honest, the judge also believed most of them, but after all, there was no real evidence, and Li Chen was not beaten, so this matter can only end like this for the time being.

This case of Li Chen's accusation of personal threats and personal harm was concluded, and the next thing to deal with was the case of Chen He's alleged theft.

The judge looked at Chen He: "The defendant is invited to make a final statement."

Chen He couldn't help but slammed his fist on the table: "It's not me! I didn't steal anything! Why don't you believe me, it's him—all framed by Chen Yuyi!"

Although he had been notified before the trial that there would be a statement by the defendant before the final decision according to the procedures, at that time Chen He had already received explicit instructions from Chen Zhuan and Chen Cheng, and they swore to him that the one who would go to prison this time was Li Chen, let him not worry.

——Chen He, out of his wholehearted trust in his two elder brothers, and because he felt that what he hadn't done, he hadn't done, so he didn't prepare any bullshit statements at all.Up to now, his mind has been completely blanked by the previous reversal, and he has no time to think about statements, and the phrase "it's not me" is repeated over and over again.

The defendant's attitude was so uncooperative, and the three judges knew it well. They first signaled him to calm down, and then began to discuss the final outcome of the case.

The presiding judge was discussing softly with the other two colleagues, and the lawyer hired by the Chen family took the opportunity to say to Chen Qi: "What you did this time is really a big mistake, I really can't help you."

Among other things, Chen Qi clamored to sue Li Chen with an edited recording, and he was the defendant's lawyer. If this matter got out, his career would be over.

Although the matter was indeed caused by Chen Qi not discussing it with him in advance, his colleagues may not necessarily listen to this explanation. People would only say that his professional ethics and professional accomplishment are not up to standard, and such a legal knowledge is not well understood, which has harmed the client.

"What do you mean? I just put up the evidence I have. How can I be so wrong?" The recording that I managed to get yesterday was completely useless. Chen Qi was already in a bad mood. As soon as he said it, he was even more angry, and the tone of his speech was extraordinarily aggressive.

The lawyer was very helpless, Chen Qi felt wronged, and he still felt wronged: "This time the amount involved is relatively large, but it is still a theft case, which belongs to the crime of ordinary theft and embezzlement, and it is not counted as an aggravated crime of theft—but Theft is not the same as theft, and the outcome of the trial is completely different."