Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 173 Unforgettable
The judge asked twice before the third person answered: "The defendant knows that I am married..."

As soon as he said this, Meng Lang almost spit out a mouthful of old blood. Was it because his dim eyes didn't see him well, or was it just the fact that Cheng Ningning lied to him?
The plaintiff and the plaintiff's lawyer were happy, and looked at the third person with a smile on their faces.

Unexpectedly, after the third person finished saying this, there was a 180-degree turn: "This is all later. She really didn't know that I was married before. I lied to her. I gave her Her 50 yuan was compensated by me voluntarily, and I am really sorry for her!"

As soon as this was said, the court fell silent.

It seems that everyone misunderstood the defendant. The defendant really didn't know that she was a mistress, and she was being mistressed.

After hearing this, Cheng Ningning immediately lay down on the dock and cried.

The plaintiff and the plaintiff's lawyer were stunned, thinking what was going on, they had said well before they came, and they wanted to stand with the plaintiff, so why did they sympathize with the defendant again?

The plaintiff stared at the third person.

"Third person, when did the defendant know that you were married?" the judge asked.

"The defendant knew about it when she proposed to marry me. At that time, I had known her for five years." The third person replied.

The judge said: "So, you have been lying to her that you have never been married?"

"Yes, I liked her at the time, but I was afraid that she would stop dating me if she knew I was married."

"Third person, this court has to remind you that your behavior is seriously irresponsible. If you do this, you are sorry to both your wife and the defendant. In other words, the 50 yuan is your voluntary compensation to the defendant. lost?"

"Yes, I gave it to her voluntarily. After all, I wasted five years of her youth." The third person lowered his head and said.

The plaintiff said anxiously at this time: "But the 50 yuan is the joint property of our husband and wife."

The judge immediately reprimanded her: "Plaintiff, this court is questioning, please don't interrupt."

The plaintiff was told something and had to sit there sulking.

The plaintiff's lawyer raised his hand and said, "Judge, the plaintiff's lawyer would like to say a few words."

Only then did the judge agree, "Say it."

The plaintiff's lawyer said: "Even if the defendant does not know that she is the mistress, the money given to her by the third party belongs to the joint property of the plaintiff and the third party, and there is no legal effect for the third party to dispose of the joint property of the husband and wife without authorization, and the defendant should return it. "

Meng Lang immediately retorted: "The plaintiff's reason is untenable. As an adult, the third party has the right to take civil action independently. It is his legal duty to compensate the defendant for cheating his feelings. Since it is his debt, he has the responsibility to repay it. The defendant no matter where his money comes from, as long as he repays it. The agreement is the true intention of both parties, and it is legal and valid. If the husband and wife have joint property rights, she should claim it to a third party instead of the defendant. It cannot be because the money is the joint property of the husband and wife. If one spouse agrees to repay but the other party does not agree to repay, the debt should not be fulfilled. Is this the truth? If so, wouldn't the husband and wife be able to evade legal responsibility if they sang the double reed?"

When Meng Lang explained this truth, the people in the court nodded repeatedly. It is only natural for the third party to compensate the defendant, because you have deceived others, and you cannot give it to the third party. If the plaintiff says no, the defendant will not be able to get compensation. Yes, this is clearly unfair.

The plaintiff's lawyer felt the pressure at this moment. It seemed that the defendant's lawyer was the best of the best, and he had thought of this.

"May I ask the defendant's lawyer, where can we see that this is the legal debt of the third party?" The plaintiff's lawyer still wants to make a dying struggle.

Meng Lang immediately replied: "The third party deceived the defendant and caused serious mental damage to the defendant. Isn't this a kind of third party's debt? If you are cheated by others, should others compensate you for your losses? ?”

These words made the plaintiff's lawyer's face turn red, and after a while, he said with a straight face: "Please don't make personal attacks on the defendant's lawyer, I'm talking about the third party defrauding the defendant, don't say what about me, what about you. "

"Very good. You admitted that the third party deceived the defendant. I don't want to say anything else, so as not to attack you personally." Meng Lang smiled slightly.

The face of the plaintiff's lawyer was even uglier.

The judge asked at this time: "Third person, where did the money you pay the defendant come from? Is it the joint property of the husband and wife?"

When the judge asked this question, everyone looked at the third person. If the third person said that it was the joint property of the husband and wife, it would still make people feel inappropriate if he disposes of it without authorization, so the plaintiff and his attorney quickly looked at the third person. , I hope he will say something that is the joint property of the husband and wife.

Meng Lang also looked at him nervously, because he knew that the 50 yuan was indeed the joint property of their husband and wife. Although he thought that even if it was the joint property of the husband and wife, it would not prevent Cheng Ningning from being compensated, but if the third person said it at this time, it must be It's not good for Cheng Ningning.

He guessed that if the third person told the truth, he might say that it was the joint property of the husband and wife, and this is exactly what the plaintiff hoped, so he hoped that the third person would tell lies and speak in favor of Cheng Ningning. .

But it seems that the dim eyes can only let him tell the truth, but not let him tell lies, which is a bit difficult to handle.

Just when everyone was feeling nervous, the third person said, "This money is money I borrowed from my friends, not the joint property of husband and wife!"

As soon as this remark came out, the plaintiff was completely dumbfounded. She immediately pointed to the third person and said, "You ungrateful, which friend of yours would lend you 50 yuan? This money is obviously our common property, how can you say it is not? I am now I want to never end with you!"

As he spoke, the plaintiff called the third person, who quickly stood up and dodged. Seeing this, the bailiff rushed up to stop him, and the plaintiff's lawyer also hurriedly persuaded him. Disturbing the order of the court is something that cannot be tolerated. Then detain.

It took a long time for the plaintiff to calm down. At this time, the judge asked: "The third person, are you sure that this money is not the joint property of the husband and wife?"

"No, I borrowed it, and I voluntarily gave it to her." The third person said firmly.

The plaintiff almost fainted from anger, and the plaintiff's lawyer was also dumbfounded. It seems that he is still obsessed with the defendant.

"Now that the court investigation is over, let's proceed to the court debate. Don't talk about the repeated content. Let's talk about the key points of the problem. Let's start with the plaintiff." After hearing this, the judge announced that he would enter the court debate stage.

After hearing this, the plaintiff's lawyer picked up the manuscript and began to read it.

(End of this chapter)