Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 437
Qin Shou was speechless when asked by Zheng Yihong, but Qin Shou still refused to admit that he killed Sun Xiaoning on purpose, so Zheng Yihong ended the interrogation again and did not ask any more questions.

Next comes the stage of proof-examination and cross-examination.

Zheng Yihong first submitted physical evidence, Sun Xiaoning's bloody clothes, which proved that Sun Xiaoning suffered trauma at the scene, and the formation of these traumas was related to Qin Shou's violent behavior.

Qian Yonghui looked at it, and then questioned: "This bloody coat does not prove that the trauma was caused by the defendant. There was no trace of fighting at the scene. How could Sun Xiaoning have trauma? It was just an accidental injury caused during a relationship. After all, the classroom is not In the bedroom, the ground is very hard and it is easy to cause trauma."

After hearing what he said, Meng Lang retorted: "The defendant turned a date into a murder scene, and said it was an accidental injury. The person who did this is a scum, and the person who said that is a scum!"

When Qian Yonghui heard this, he became angry and said to the judge: "The victim's representative insulted my personality again. I request the court to admonish the victim's representative and expel him from the court."

The judge listened carefully to his words, then turned his head to Meng Lang and said, "The victim's attorney, please pay attention to your words, and don't make an example."

"Good presiding judge." Meng Lang said, "I take back my words. The defendant's lawyer is not a scum or a beast, okay?"

After hearing this, Qian Yonghui stared at him, extremely angry.

Zheng Yihong continued to produce evidence. The next set of evidence was the autopsy report, which proved that the cause of Sun Xiaoning's death was suffocation.

Qian Yonghui then cross-examined and said: "The defender has no objection to the cause of the victim's death, but has objections to the means of causing the victim's death by suffocation. The current evidence can only prove that the victim's death was caused by negligence or indirect intention. , when the defendant left the scene, the victim did not die, and the defendant just took a laissez-faire mental attitude towards the death result at this time, which constituted indirect intention rather than direct intention."

Qian Yonghui argued that Qin Shou's behavior was indirect intentional, because he knew that it was impossible to turn this case into manslaughter. The public prosecution agency charged Qin Shou with intentional homicide. , it is impossible to say that black is white, and that his behavior is manslaughter.

And the defense is indirect intentional homicide, although it is still intentional homicide, but compared with direct intentional, the crime is relatively minor.

But when he said this, Zheng Yihong retorted: "The defendant argued that the victim was still alive when he left the scene. This is just his one-sided statement. In fact, according to the autopsy report, the victim died of suffocation in a short time. When the defendant left, There’s no way he’s still alive.”

Qian Yonghui listened, but insisted: "The autopsy report did not state the time of the victim's death, and the statement that the time of death from suffocation was relatively fast is very vague, and cannot overturn the defendant's defense."

At this time, Meng Lang also questioned: "The defendant called the police after the incident and said that he had killed someone. If he found that the victim was not dead when he left, how could he say that he had killed someone when he called the police? This is obviously self-contradictory." , therefore, the defendant's statement is nothing more than another nonsense sophistry."

After the three parties debated, Zheng Yihong then presented witnesses' testimony to prove the circumstances of the discovery of the body. On this point, Qian Yonghui had nothing to justify.

However, when the witness proved that the relationship between Qin Shou and Sun Xiaoning was not in love, Qian Yonghui immediately questioned: "The testimony of the witness is not true. Whether the defendant and the victim only have a love relationship, only they know , no one else can know."

After hearing this, Zheng Yihong said: "These witnesses are all classmates and friends who are very close friends with Sun Xiaoning. Sun Xiaoning will tell them whether Sun Xiaoning likes the defendant. This is enough to prove that the defendant and the victim are not in love. Looking at the situation afterwards, it is impossible for them to be in a relationship of love and friendship. The defendant said that they were dating the victim. Under normal circumstances, the victim would not be able to date the defendant in the classroom. The classroom is a place for learning, even at night. Will meet people, they can't possibly come to the classroom to date, and have sex!"

Qian Yonghui glanced at Zheng Yihong, but immediately retorted: "The prosecutor just said that this is impossible, that is impossible, but there is no evidence to rule out all possibilities, and if reasonable doubt cannot be ruled out, there is no way to prove it, and it cannot be denied. The possibility mentioned by the defendant!”

After hearing Qian Yonghui's words, Meng Lang looked at Qian Yonghui and said, "What the prosecutor said cannot be a normal reasoning, just like you cannot eat shit. Do I have to rule out all reasonable doubts? ? Indeed, the possibility of eating shit cannot be ruled out, because there are indeed people who eat shit in history, right?"

These words made Qian Yonghui's face green, which is insulting him again.

"Report to the presiding judge, the victim's representative has seriously defiled the sacred environment of the court with his words, and should be expelled from the court!" Qian Yonghui complained to the judge again.

The judge couldn't help touching his nose. Meng Lang's words were indeed a bit indecent, but they sounded quite reasonable. Daily experience can't rule out all possibilities, but if you question it, it's an insult. It's just a metaphor of eating shit, vulgar some.

"Victim's attorney, you can use other metaphors to avoid the smell in the courtroom." When the judge finished speaking, he actually laughed, although it was only a slight smile.

Meng Lang also smiled, and said, "Report to the presiding judge, the courtroom is really smelly, because someone's mouth is stinky, turning black and white, and I won't talk about eating shit, lest someone get upset and think I'm talking about it." He eats shit, actually I didn’t mention him by name, and if someone insists on matching his name, I can’t do anything about it.”

Qian Yonghui stared again at what he said. He felt that facing a rogue lawyer like Meng Lang would simply lower his status.

Zheng Yihong also laughed when she saw this scene. Meng Lang didn't follow the routine today, but he said what she couldn't say as a public prosecutor, which made her feel extremely refreshed.

"Please continue to present evidence, the public prosecutor." The judge was actually happy in his heart. Qin Shou was so young and his morals were so bad, if he was allowed to talk nonsense in court, it would be too cheap for him.

After hearing the judge's words, Zheng Yihong looked down at the materials and said, "The following is a set of documentary evidence to prove the defendant's age, so as to prove that the defendant has reached the age of criminal responsibility."

According to the law, anyone who has reached the age of sixteen needs to bear criminal responsibility, and the public prosecutor needs to prove that Qin Shou is over the age of sixteen.

(End of this chapter)