Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 438 There is a problem with the evidence

Zheng Yihong submitted Qin Shou's household registration certificate and birth certificate without even looking at the evidence to prove that Qin Shou was over [-] years old.

However, at the age of [-], he has only reached the age of criminal responsibility. If he is under the age of [-], he still cannot be sentenced to death. This is what Sun Xiaoning's parents have always worried about. Seeing that this beast, which is not as good as a beast, is still alive and kicking after the judgment, although they resent this injustice, they can't fight against the law, because that's what the law stipulates, underage victims can be killed, and underage victims The perpetrators cannot be sentenced to death.

After the evidence was submitted, it was handed over to the defender for cross-examination. Qian Yonghui picked up the evidence but ignored it, and then cross-examined: "There is no objection to this evidence. The defendant was under [-] years old when the case was committed. Although he should be responsible Criminal responsibility, but the death penalty cannot be applied according to law."

After Qian Yonghui finished the cross-examination, it was the victim's turn to express his cross-examination opinion. Meng Lang took the birth certificate and the household registration certificate and glanced at it. Suddenly, his eyes lit up with a look of surprise on his face. What's going on? , Qin Shou's age was born on September [-]th, but looking at it now, he was born on August [-]st, and the crime happened on August [-]rd. In this way, he was full when the crime happened. Eighteen years old, if it was born on September [-]th, it is under the age of eighteen, what's going on?

Could it be that he is delusional?

Meng Lang looked it over again carefully. It was indeed born on August [-]st. Could it be that he had misread it before?

He took the evidence and looked at it for a long time. When the judge saw it, he urged him to cross-examine the evidence as soon as possible without wasting time. He hurriedly said, "What the defender said just now is wrong. The defendant was clearly eighteen years old when the case happened, and the death penalty can be applied according to law." , the defender cross-examined wrongly."

As soon as this remark came out, not only the defender was surprised, but also the judge and Zheng Yihong. This case was obviously a case of juvenile crime, why is it suddenly not a juvenile?Is the evidence wrong?

Before Zheng Yihong could respond, Qian Yonghui immediately said, "Impossible, the defendant was born on September [-]th, and the crime happened on August [-]st, how could he be eighteen years old when the crime happened?" Woolen cloth?"

Meng Lang pointed to the evidence in his hand and said, "Who said he was born on September [-]th? He was obviously born on August [-]st, and the time of the crime happened on August [-]rd, which happened to be [-] years old."

"Impossible, I'll look at the evidence again." Qian Yonghui immediately became anxious. This evidence can be said to be the most important evidence for Qin Shou in this case. It is not an exaggeration to say that it is the gold medal for avoiding death. If there is no piece of evidence, or if this piece of evidence fails to prove that he is a minor, Qin Shou may be sentenced to death.

Meng Lang smiled and handed over the evidence to the bailiff, who then handed the evidence to Qian Yonghui.

Qian Yonghui picked up the evidence and looked at it carefully for a long time. He didn't look at the evidence at all just now, because he knew that Qin Shou was under eighteen years old, so there was no need to look at such evidence carefully.

Now he took the evidence and looked at it for a long time, and the top of his head began to sweat, thinking how could this be possible, Qin Shou's age was obviously born on September [-]th, he had read the original evidence many times, how could it be changed now? August [-]st?Moreover, the age recorded in the birth certificate is the same as that recorded in the household registration certificate. If it is said that it has been tampered with, why can't there be any traces of tampering?

Could it be that he saw it wrong?Or are you just blinded now?

He carefully read it twice again, no matter how he looked at it, it was August [-]st, not September [-]th, this is really fucking evil, it feels like a supernatural event.

"This evidence is wrong. It is definitely not the defendant's birth certificate and household registration certificate. The prosecutor submitted the wrong evidence." Qian Yonghui threw the evidence on the table and yelled.

Meng Lang looked at him and said, "What's wrong? The ID number is correct, and the content is also correct. Why isn't it the defendant's birth certificate and household registration certificate? You misunderstood it, right?"

"I can't be mistaken. The defendant was not eighteen years old when the case happened." Qian Yonghui insisted.

Meng Lang said: "You said that if you are not full, you are not full. What about the evidence? This evidence clearly proves that he is eighteen years old."

"This evidence is false, false!" Qian Yonghui argued.

Meng Lang refuted him: "If you say it's fake, it's fake? This evidence was obtained by the investigation agency through legal procedures, and there is nothing false about it."

Qian Yonghui was in a hurry, looked at the judge and said, "Report to the presiding judge, this evidence is questionable, please investigate carefully and find out the truth."

The judge was also surprised and said, "Show the evidence."

The bailiff handed the evidence to the judge. The judge knew something about it. Now that he got the evidence, he took a quick look and found that it was what Meng Lang said. Qin Shou's date of birth was indeed August [-]st. , instead of September [-]th.

Although Qian Yonghui said that this evidence is fake, it doesn't look like a forgery, does it?What should I do now?Is it to confirm the authenticity of this evidence, or to follow the defender's argument and say it is false?

"Please let the prosecutor look at this set of evidence again." The judge thought for a while and handed the difficult problem to Zheng Yihong.

Zheng Yihong was naturally full of suspicion at this time. She also remembered that Qin Shou was less than [-] years old, and now she suddenly discovered that he was over [-] years old. This was an important change in evidence, and the prosecution opinion must be revised accordingly.

After taking the evidence and reading it carefully twice, Zheng Yihong said: "This evidence was obtained legally by the investigative agency. Legality does not matter. The authenticity has been carefully checked by the prosecutor and there is no problem. Authenticity, legality, objectivity are consistent with each other, this set of evidence can be used as the basis for finalizing the case.”

Zheng Yihong was also thinking about how to severely punish this guy who refused to plead guilty and was still talking nonsense here, so she didn't show a very surprised look and accepted the evidence.

When Qian Yonghui heard this, he immediately said: "No, this evidence is obviously false. The defender asked the investigative agency to obtain evidence again and obtain relevant evidence."

Zheng Yihong retorted: "Now there is no objection to the authenticity of the evidence, and there is no need to collect evidence again. The defender's request has no legal basis."

Qian Yonghui said: "The defender has sufficient evidence to show that there are problems with the evidence, because the defendant's parents told the defender that the defendant's birthday is September [-]th, and the defendant himself said it was September [-]th. Could it be August [-]st?"

(End of this chapter)