Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 445 Don't Give False Testimony

"I don't want to testify. Little Shou Ma insisted on asking me to testify. I remember it was ten days, but maybe 20 days. Forget it, I won't testify." The old lady panicked and told the court.

Seeing that the old lady surrendered so quickly, Qian Yonghui was very angry, but there was nothing he could do. When the prosecutor saw it, he felt happy for a moment. Unexpectedly, the victim's attorney dismissed the witness directly. .

When the judge saw it, he said to the old lady: "Testifying in court is a very serious matter. If you are not sure about what you are testifying about, do not go to court to testify. Now the court will confirm it for you again. Do you continue to testify?" "

"I won't do it, I won't do it, I didn't want to do it at first, it's because my mother insisted that I do it." The old lady kept muttering for a long time.

When the judge saw it, he asked the bailiff to take the witness down.

Qian Yonghui watched helplessly as Meng Lang was spoiled by this testimony.

Then another witness was called to court.

Or Qian Yonghui will ask first.

"Do you know the defendant?"

"Yes, our family is neighbors with theirs."

"Do you know when his birthday is?"

"September [-]th, the same birthday as my son."

"Are you sure your son has the same birthday as him?"

"I remember, we celebrated our birthday together."

"Is your memory correct?"

"How could it be wrong? I remember it clearly."

"Were you born in the same hospital?"

"Born in the same hospital, mine is a daughter and his is a son."

Hearing the witness's answer, Qian Yonghui was very satisfied, and told the judge that he was done with the questioning.

When it was the turn of the prosecutor who appeared in court to ask questions, the prosecutor who appeared in court simply asked: "Do you have relevant evidence to prove that your son and the defendant have the same birthday?"

"No, but we were born together."

After the prosecutor's questioning, it was meng lang's turn to ask again.

"What is your relationship with the defendant?"

"We are neighbors."

"Since when have you been neighbors?"

"We've been neighbors since the baby was born."

"What day was your child born?"

"September eleventh."

"What day was the defendant born?"

"It's also September [-]th."

"Are you sure?"

"I'm sure."

"What does your daughter usually call the defendant?"

"Call her sister."

"Why do you call her sister?"

"Because he's a little older than my daughter."

"How much bigger is bigger?"

"About a few hours older."

"Are you sure?"

"I'm sure."

"Do you have any evidence?"

"I have a birth certificate proving when my daughter was born."

"Have you seen the defendant's birth certificate?"

"No."

"You haven't seen his birth certificate, how can you be sure that he was born with your daughter?"

"But he was indeed born with my daughter."

"I tell you now, his birth certificate shows the date of August [-]st, not September [-]st. How can that be?"

After hearing this, the female witness said with wide eyes: "How is that possible? I clearly remember that he and my daughter had the same birthday."

"You clearly remember that they were born on the same day, but his current birth certificate is not on the same day as your daughter. How do you explain this?"

As soon as the question came to this point, Qian Yonghui protested again: "This kind of thing should not be explained by witnesses."

After hearing this, the judge just glanced at him and said to Meng Lang: "The victim's attorney, please continue."

Qian Yonghui held his breath again.

The witness looked at Meng Lang and said, "Then I don't know what happened. I remember that he and my daughter had the same birthday."

"You just said that you also celebrated your birthday together. When did that happen?"

"About ten years ago, we had our birthday together."

"Do you still remember what happened ten years ago?"

"We celebrate our birthday together, and we can still remember it clearly."

"Can you remember you guys having birthdays together because your two kids are on the same day?"

"That's how I remember it."

"You remember that, but what if it's not the case? It's not necessarily because the two of you have birthdays together, is it?"

"I remember that was the case, same birthday," the witness insisted.

"Do you know that memory can be biased? And it was ten years ago. You remember that you celebrated your birthday together. It may be because one of your families celebrated a birthday and invited another family to come over for dinner. Isn't this normal?"

"Protest, the victim's representative induced my witness to speak again." Qian Yonghui stood up and objected again.

"The testimony of a witness must pass the test. Defender, you must listen carefully to the questioning of the victim's attorney." The judge was not very happy.Seeing this, Qian Yonghui really wanted to walk away. The judge completely sided with the victim.

After hearing Meng Lang's words, the witness didn't know what to say for a while. After Meng Lang said this, she really couldn't remember whether it was because of the same birthday dinner, or because one family had a child's birthday and invited another family to have dinner together.

"I have the impression that we have the same birthday. As for whether we celebrated our birthday together, I can't remember clearly." The witness had no choice but to answer in this way.

"You can't remember clearly, but do you still remember that they both have the same birthday?"

"Yes."

"How are you sure you remember that they both have the same birthday?"

"I remember I was born on the same day as his mother."

"Didn't you just say that they were born in the same hospital, now how do you say they were born in the same birth?"

"We were born in the same hospital, in the same hospital."

"But the defendant's birth certificate clearly stated that he was born on August [-]st, not September [-]th. How do you explain it? Could the hospital advance his birth date by more than a month?"

"No way? How is it possible?" The witness was surprised.

"The birth certificate is infallible, but is your memory infallible?"

"I... I remember that they were indeed born with the same person."

"Do you still remember clearly what happened 18 years ago?"

The witness began to scratch his head, and was a little confused.

"Did he stay in the hospital when he was a child, and we happened to meet each other, and then I felt that we were born together?" Meng Lang didn't need to say more, and the witness began to doubt himself.

"I have never been in a hospital." After hearing this, Qin Shou hurriedly shouted next to him.

The judge immediately stopped him and said, "The defendant, don't talk indiscriminately. You can talk when it's your turn." Qin Shou said something.

"What you are talking about now is your own feeling. Feelings are unreliable, and memory is also biased. Only evidence can make no mistakes. The birth certificate clearly stated that the defendant's birthday was August [-]st. You said it was September [-]th. Day, this is wrong, if you insist on testifying like this, you will be giving false testimony." Meng Lang said to the witness earnestly.

(End of this chapter)