Becoming a lawyer starts with raising a Xiezhi

Chapter 446
Witnesses confuse themselves. People's memory is really biased, so witness testimony is the most unstable evidence, especially the kind of testimony that happened many years ago. Who can remember it so clearly?

Things may have that thing, but if you ask you to say the specific time and date, it will be difficult.

And when they testified in court, what they proved was precisely such things as time and date. How could they remember so accurately?
The female witness asked Meng Lang to question her for a long time, and then she became dizzy. She couldn't determine Qin Shou's date of birth, because the birth certificate could best prove Qin Shou's date of birth. How could she compare it to the birth certificate? Still clear?
Qian Yonghui's idea of ​​overturning Qin Shou's date of birth through the testimony of witnesses failed. This was his only way. Besides, he had no better way to overthrow the evidence of Qin Shou's date of birth.

When the prosecutors who appeared in court saw that Meng Lang had left the two witnesses speechless and sat there, they were very happy, because it saved them a lot of trouble. They didn't ask the witnesses too many things, but only asked if the witnesses had any questions. Evidence, if there is no evidence, should be based on written evidence, because documentary evidence is more effective than verbal evidence.

However, after meng lang's questioning, getting the witness to voluntarily admit that his testimony was inaccurate would make the defendant more convinced.

Seeing that the witness testimony could not have the expected effect, Qian Yonghui was a little anxious and had to tell the court: "The defendant's age cannot rule out reasonable doubt, and what the witness said cannot be completely ruled out. Therefore, for the defendant The issue of a person’s age should be cast into doubt and the defendant should not be sentenced to death.”

With the judge's permission, Meng Lang retorted: "There is no doubt about the defendant's age. The so-called doubt is just artificially created. The so-called empty words are empty. Now the birth certificate and household registration certificate clearly prove the defendant's age. What is there to say? If the birth certificate cannot prove the defendant’s age, what else can it prove? The evidence in the case is sufficient to determine that the defendant was eighteen years old at the time of the crime.”

On the issue of age, the two parties have already had a heated debate, and it depends on how the second-instance judge decides.

Qian Yonghui also had no other evidence to submit, so the judge sorted out the focus of the case and entered the courtroom debate. At this time, Qian Yonghui said: "The defendant is willing to plead guilty now and asks the court to give him a lighter punishment."

After hearing this, the judge looked at Qin Shou and asked, "Defendant, what's your opinion now?"

At this time, Qin Shou had no choice but to follow Qian Yonghui's persuasion and plead guilty in court in order to get a lighter treatment, at least not to be sentenced to death.

So he bowed his head and said: "I am willing to plead guilty. I admit that I killed her. I killed her on purpose, not by negligence."

"Why did you kill the victim?" the judge asked.

"After I had sex with her, we had a quarrel, and in a fit of anger, I killed her."

"Why did you quarrel?"

"Because she said she wanted to break up with me."

"Why did she break up with me?"

"I don't know, anyway, she said that from now on, she won't talk to me about boyfriend and girlfriend. When I was in a hurry, I strangled her neck and strangled her to death."

"Are you telling the truth?"

"I am telling the truth."

Qin Shou once again evaded the most serious, only admitting intentional homicide, but not rape, because if robbery and rape were added, his crime would be more serious, and if it was just intentional homicide, the possibility of a lesser punishment would be greater.

The judge asked the prosecutor who appeared in court whether he had any questions to question the defendant.

The prosecutor who appeared in court asked: "The existing evidence shows that you and the victim have no boyfriend and girlfriend relationship, so you say that the victim proposed to break up with you, which is seriously inconsistent with the facts. Since you said you are willing to plead guilty, you must admit all crimes. It is impossible for you to be punished lightly with your current attitude of pleading guilty."

Qin Shou listened to the prosecutor who appeared in court, looked up at the prosecutor who appeared in court, his expression froze, but he still said: "We are really boyfriend and girlfriend, what others said is a lie."

"If you are in a relationship of boyfriend and girlfriend, and the victim wants to break up with you that day, how can she have sex with you again? The victim has never had sex with anyone else before. Why did she want to have sex with you when she broke up? Happened? You still refuse to admit the relevant criminal facts, and it is absolutely correct to sentence you to death in the first instance."

The inspector who appeared in court scolded Qin Shou. Qin Shou bowed his head, but he still had no intention of repenting, because he felt that as long as he admitted the fact of robbery, he would really be guilty of a heinous crime. He still couldn't admit it. .

After the prosecutor who appeared in court finished questioning, Meng Lang asked to question Qin Shou.

Looking at Qin Shou, Meng Lang asked, "Why did you call the victim out in the middle of the night?"

"She asked me out."

"You still say she asked you out?"

"She was the one who asked me out."

"Who made that call?"

"I hit it."

"Why are you fighting?"

"Because I miss her."

"and then?"

"And then she asked me out."

"What did she want to do when she asked you out?"

"Just to meet."

"Would a girl ask you out to meet in the middle of the night?"

"What's wrong in the middle of the night, don't we all meet at night for dating?"

"Who suggested the date?"

"is her."

"Why did you ask to meet in the classroom?"

"The school door was closed at that time, and we only had an appointment to meet in the classroom."

"What did you do after meeting?"

"After meeting, she took the initiative to hug me, and then we had sex."

"According to what you said, the victim couldn't wait to have sex with you?"

"Yes, that's what she did."

"Since she is so desperate to have sex with you, why didn't she call you?"

"Wouldn't it be the same if I hit her?"

"You mean, are you in a relationship?"

"That's it."

"What does it mean? Yes or no?"

"Yes."

"Since you are in love, you will have more opportunities to meet each other. Why do you still come out to meet at this time?"

"When will we come out to meet, does anyone else care?"

"I don't care about you, but would a girl ask to have sex with you at this time? The classroom is an open place. Would a girl choose to have sex with you in this place?"

"How is it impossible? We are in love, and it is possible to have a relationship anywhere."

"You are in love one by one, then let me ask you, why did the victim propose to break up after you had a relationship?"

Meng Lang suddenly asked Qin Shou loudly.

(End of this chapter)