Conan: The winner is justice

"Let's take a closer look at the plagiarized paragraphs."

Mao Lilan pointed to the documents on the whiteboard.

At this time, she gradually entered the state and her speech gradually became fluent.

"This paragraph was written by our client, the original author."

"'It was very cold, the north wind was blowing, and the poor civet cat was so hungry that it had to give up the temporary haystack that it found to shelter from the cold, and ran to the freezing road to find food. .'"

"And this paragraph was written by the defendant Daisuke Tokura."

"'The weather was so cold that it made the black cat sneeze, and there was a cold wind blowing. The trembling black cat's stomach growled with hunger. It had to give up the warm haystack and ran out of the house to find something to eat. thing.'"

"The content and context of these two paragraphs are almost exactly the same. I just slightly modified the grammatical paragraphs and turned them into my own. This kind of plagiarism is pure whitewashing. It is really abominable and does not take into account the hard work of the original author. Take it seriously!"

At the end of the sentence, Mao Lilan's voice became louder and louder, and she was very emotional.

You can see that the horns on her head have stood up and started to twist around again, looking very angry.

"Little girl, you can't come here just by opening your mouth."

Different from Mao Lilan's angry mood, the opposing lawyer looked relaxed.

"As for the plaintiff's novel and our client's novel, in terms of subject matter, both are animal themes, and there is a certain degree of similarity. As we all know, the behavior of animals is very monotonous in the eyes of humans. If we only rely on some natural and hunting behavior, it would be ridiculous to conclude that the novel contains plagiarism!”

"Can't this be called plagiarism? These two passages look exactly the same!"

Mao Lilan slammed the table angrily, making a violent sound.

"Little girl, didn't you hear that just now?"

The defendant's lawyer was obviously very arrogant and did not take the other party's plagiarism accusations seriously. "

"Our point of view has already been explained. The similarity of the paragraphs is due to the subject matter! The two novels are both about animals. There is a certain degree of similarity in the behavior of the protagonists. It is normal to have some sense of déjà vu. What you said does not constitute evidence at all. ! Little girl, I still advise you, at your age, you should go back and read more books. The law is not a child’s play, and the court is not a place that teenagers can enter! "

Facing the ridicule of the enemy lawyer, Mao Lilan immediately said angrily: "I don't treat law as a child's play. I have been studying it with my mother for a long time!"

As soon as the last words "Mom" came out, there was another burst of laughter in the court.

The one who laughed the loudest was Gu Meimen in the auditorium.

He even stood up and gave her a round of applause.

Mao Lilan blinked and realized that he shouldn't speak like that, and his face suddenly turned red.

"It's really eye-opening for me!"

Before the judge struck the hammer, Gu Meimen immediately sat down again and sneered.

"Look at this silly Baitian, who still wants to be a lawyer with this kind of personality? Aren't you going to be led by the other party's lead?"

"You're here again."

Xiao Ai's eyes narrowed.

"Since you think she is not suitable to be a lawyer, then you gave her some advice before and asked her to start studying civil law first?"

"Can't I have some fun?" Gu Meimen rolled his eyes, "The most important thing for a lawyer is to make a calm judgment. In court, you have to be calm and calm in the face of danger, otherwise the other party will use random words to induce you. She fell into the trap, just like she did just now, saying all the words she learned from her mother, but not making people laugh? "

"All right."

Xiao Ai glanced at Mao Lilan, who was blushing with shame in the court.

"However, after all, this is her first lawsuit. You can't ask too much of a newcomer."

"I mean, she is too serious, or too serious."

Gu Meimen shook his head and said so.

"I told you before, right? Civil litigation is different from criminal litigation. There will be more cases of settlement between the two parties."

"You must have heard about it, right? A few days ago, Tokura Daisuke went to the plaintiff and said he wanted peace talks. As a result, Mao Lilan, as the agent, refused without even thinking, saying that he must The lawsuit will be fought to the end.”

"In today's society, everything is full of tact and compromise. Many lawsuits don't even need to be fought. Both parties can just settle the matter in private. It's good for you, me and him to suppress the matter and pay a sum of money to seal the matter casually."

"Do you think a person with a sincere personality like Mao Lilan will be popular as a lawyer in the future?"

Hearing this, Xiao Ai turned her head and stared at Gu Meimen carefully.

"Why are you looking at me like that?" Gu Meimen raised his eyebrows, "Is there something wrong with what I said? Or do you think Mao Lilan is suitable to be a lawyer?"

Xiao Ai looked back and raised the corners of her mouth slightly: "There's nothing wrong, it's quite right."

under.

The referee still needs to proceed.

“The determination of plagiarism in novels must be based on formal distinction.”

Civil law, unlike criminal law, has a very broad scope.

Generally speaking, each lawyer will only have their own expertise in different areas.

As Daisuke Tokura's consulting lawyer, the other party's lawyer is very obvious that he is quite professional in the field of copyright law.

"Generally speaking, even if a plot or a technique has similar parts, it can only be called a reference."

"For example, Kudo Yusaku, the most famous mystery novelist in the world today, has repeatedly used fishing line, piano wire, cyanide and other such props in his mystery novels."

"If I were to write a mystery novel, I would also design a plot in which the prisoner uses fishing line to commit the crime."

"Excuse me, can I be considered plagiarized?"

There was a murmur in the courtroom.

Everyone in the auditorium nodded.

The examples given by Tokura Daisuke’s lawyer are very informative.

Kudo Yusaku is the most famous mystery novelist in the world. The main reason why he is so popular is that his novels have unique creativity.

After he became popular, some people naturally began to imitate his works.

From this, many schools were born, such as the "Cyanide School", "Fishing Line School", etc. - because the criminal methods in his novels are all written in this way.

Not to mention the creation of novels, even many criminals in life have begun to imitate the techniques in his novels to commit crimes and kill people.

Things like fishing line, piano wire, cyanide, etc. were basically learned from his novels.

"I think Kudo Yusaku should be arrested first. The novels he wrote are very harmful."

When this topic was brought up, Xiao Ai couldn't help but complain.

"I have read his novels and seen many crime cases. The methods of many people committing crimes and killings are exactly the same as what is written in his novels. He is a public figure, and he is a very famous person who has a huge impact on society. , if you accuse him of abetting a crime, he shouldn’t be able to run away, right?”