Conan: The winner is justice

However, Gu Meimen shook his head in response to Xiao Ai's complaints.

"You can't sue him."

"Why?" Xiao Ai asked.

"First of all, Kudo Yusaku created and published the novel, which does not constitute subjective instigation. It is not subjectively established."

Gu Meimen explained.

"Secondly, the instigator must form an accomplice relationship with the person who is instigated to commit the crime. Since you have read the novels he wrote, you should know that there are many loopholes in the novels he wrote, and many logics conflict with reality. Therefore, objectively, his behavior is enough to avoid abetting the truth."

"I understand, neither subjective nor objective principles are established."

Xiao Ai nodded, but frowned again.

"But so many people imitate the plots in his novels and commit crimes. In the end, although these people may be arrested, they are still killed. Does he really have no responsibility at all?"

Kudo Yusaku's novels have a profound impact.

It has even affected the economic operations of many regions.

For example, the sale of cyanide should originally be prohibited. Japan's "Poisons and Highly Poisonous Substances Control Law" clearly stipulates that such highly toxic substances must be regulated.

But in Japan, this thing is quite popular in the underground market.

Even among the drugs smuggled by customs every year, cyanide often ranks among the top.

Basically this is an indirect result of the novel written by Kudo Yusaku.

Don’t underestimate the impact that novels can have.

There is a saying that goes, the harm a pen can do is far greater than the power of a gun.

If he was not guilty, then those who died were also unjust.

"Even if you say so, there is no evidence to take him down."

Gu Meimen paused and said this.

"Unless he wrote a novel, the logic of this novel is so perfect that in reality, the plot of the novel can be copied 100% to constitute a crime, and the novel has a certain influence. Then, as long as a person imitates the story in the novel and commits a crime, According to the principle of responsibility doctrine, if it constitutes a censure condition, he can be arrested and dealt with as an indirect principal offender of abetting crime."

Criticism, that is, the possibility of censure, was also mentioned by Kudo Yusaku before. (See Chapter 117)

This is the concept in German and Japanese criminal law, that is, "responsibility."

Its meaning is that when the perpetrator is responsible for the objective illegal behavior and should be condemned, this behavior is a crime.

In other words, no matter how you defend yourself subjectively, your behavior objectively constitutes the conditions for a crime, and you are committing a crime.

"Then it's quite difficult."

After hearing this, Xiao Ai shook his head and sighed.

"With Kudo Yusaku's IQ, it is impossible for him to make such a mistake. Those who died because of the techniques in his novels could only die in vain."

Gu Meimen shrugged: "If such a highly intelligent person commits a crime, it would be difficult to catch him."

The two of them were talking to each other in the spectator seats.

However, at this time, they did not know that the content of this conversation would actually become a part of the conversation in the future.

under.

Mao Lilan's lawsuit is still ongoing.

Regarding the defense of the other party's lawyer, and the echoes from around him.

Perhaps she was too nervous, or perhaps she was inexperienced. Mao Lilan's cheeks turned red and she couldn't answer.

"How about it, don't you have anything to say?"

The opposing lawyer looked proud.

After a long time, Mao Lilan hesitated and choked out a sentence.

"You, the situation in the example you gave is completely different from these two books!"

The opposing lawyer said arrogantly: "Then tell me, why is it different?"

"Of course it's different! The situation you mentioned can only be regarded as a reference to a certain plot, and of course it cannot be regarded as plagiarism! But if the author is writing a novel, the characters, scenes, psychology, character states, etc. are all If there are any similarities, then this is definitely plagiarism and violates the requirements of the Japanese Copyright Law!"

The opposing lawyer was stunned for a moment, and then his face turned ugly.

Obviously, the girl in front of him was not stupid, and she actually discovered his sophistry.

Seeing the other party's lawyer's expression, Mao Lilan let out a sigh of relief and smiled, knowing that he was right.

"According to our investigation, the novel written by the defendant falls into the situation I just mentioned! Including the scenes, characters' psychology, states, behaviors, etc., entire paragraphs are plagiarized!"

Mao Lilan stretched out her right hand and gently wiped the sweat from her forehead, trying to calm down her nervousness.

“According to the provisions of the Copyright Law, the quotation of non-poetry works shall not exceed 2,500 words or one-tenth of the cited work. If a work has more than 5 text similarities, it can be regarded as mild plagiarism; if there are more than 10 similarities, It can be regarded as serious plagiarism; if there are more than 20 similarities, it should be regarded as plagiarism; if there are more than 30 similarities, it is serious plagiarism!"

There was a pause.

Mao Lilan took out a document and slapped it on the whiteboard in the middle of the courtroom.

Marked on the paper is a column chart.

"We have strictly compared the paragraphs of the two books and found that there are more than 30 parts of the content, which can be regarded as serious plagiarism! I can't understand why people can be so shameless! This kind of complete disregard of other authors The creative efforts should be taken seriously and should, must, and be strictly punished by law!"

The more Mao Lilan talked, the more excited she became. She couldn't help but stretched out her palm again and slapped it hard on the table of the lawyer's table.

Just listen to a "click".

The center of the table made of mahogany actually looked like a crack, spreading to all sides to form cracks!

"..."

"..."

There was silence in the courtroom.

Everyone looked at the table under her hands eagerly.

The huge strength of the girl in front of him almost shocked everyone.

"She is still so strong." Xiao Ai sighed.

"Is this guy human?"

Gu Meimen on the side showed a smacking expression: "Look, how can a woman like this, who only cares about muscles, have the nerve to stand in court? The judge on the stage should kick her out immediately!"

There was a pause.

Gu Meimen then looked at the bodyguard Aso Minoru who was sitting next to him and had been silent.

"How do you think your strength compares with hers?"

Aso thought for a while, shook his head and said, "I'm not sure. I can't judge until I have a specific fight."

"Yeah?"

Gu Meimen curled her lips.

"I think you're all pretty much the same. You're all freaks."

In court.

After Mao Lilan slapped him down, he obviously realized that his behavior was too rude.

She blushed, stuck out her tongue, and quickly bowed around her.

"Sorry, I'm rude."

At this time, the judge on the stage also came to his senses, looked at her strangely, and then looked in the direction of the defendant.

“Do the defendants and their attorneys have any opinions on the plaintiff’s litigation viewpoint?”

The regulations and evidence listed by Mao Lilan can be said to be quite sufficient.

If there is no reasonable rebuttal from the defendant, then this lawsuit can determine that the defendant has plagiarized.